title: "Citation Integrity Spot-Check Report — Full Audit v1.5, 2026-05-05" type: audit-report date: 2026-05-05 phase: 6
Citation Integrity Spot-Check — 2026-05-05
Run summary
This is the third citation-integrity spot-check run since the wiki's General Rule 16 was codified (origin: 2026-04-25 audit; second run: 2026-04-28). Since the 2026-04-28 run, ~13 ingests have landed (Heidegger Nietzsche I/II, Heidegger 1964 End of Philosophy, MP 1992 Texts and Dialogues, MP 2022 Inédits I, MP 2022 Inédits II, Chouraqui 2025 Healing Schneider, MP 1947 Humanism and Terror, MP 2010 Sorbonne lectures, Morris 2024 Wild Structure and Melting Time, Décarie-Daigneault 2024 Crooked Finger, MP 1942 Structure of Behavior) and 7 Phase 8 runs (runs 2–7) have produced ~80 claim entries (6 supported / 43 live / 31 candidate per the 2026-05-05 seventh-run report). No citation re-sample has been done across that frontier since 2026-04-28.
The scope per AUDIT_PLAN v1.5 §Phase 6 is: (A) weighted random sample of 25 citations biased toward (a) authors not in raw/, (b) audit-produced pages from Phase 8 runs 2–7, and (c) concept pages substantially updated by post-2026-04-28 ingests; plus (B) deterministic sweeps for the Faul fabrication pattern, the Saint Aubert 2006/2013 mediated framing, supported-claim full re-verification, Phase 8 runs 2–7 evidence anchor enumeration, and Synthetic Claims sections cite-back accuracy; plus (C) Rule 18 retrospective relevance checks on ≥3 priority targets. Report-only — no edits.
Sample composition (25 citations)
The sample is biased per AUDIT_PLAN R3 / Phase 6 sample design: ~10 from authors not directly in raw/, ~10 from audit-produced pages (Phase 8 runs 2–7), ~5 from concept pages substantially updated by post-2026-04-28 ingests.
| # | Source category | Page / location | Citation sampled |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Author-not-in-raw (Saint Aubert 2006) | indirect-ontology § "Saint Aubert's Vers une ontologie indirecte (Vrin, 2006)" line 54–58 | "Saint Aubert's monograph-level Vers une ontologie indirecte (Vrin, 2006) is a distinct named framework..." |
| 2 | Author-not-in-raw (Saint Aubert 2006) | empietement § "Saint Aubert's five-volume method" line 81–86 | "Vers une ontologie indirecte, 2006" — bibliographic listing in five-volume sequence |
| 3 | Author-not-in-raw (Saint Aubert 2006) | science-secrete line 188 | "ingesting Saint Aubert 2006 Vers une ontologie indirecte — the most consequential raw/ absence" |
| 4 | Author-not-in-raw (Saint Aubert 2013) | ambiguity-vs-ambivalence line 162–166 | "saintaubert-2013-etre-et-chair-i (Ch VII) elaborate the full genealogy of the distinction" |
| 5 | Author-not-in-raw (Saint Aubert 2013) | ambiguity-vs-ambivalence line 258 | "saintaubert-2013-etre-et-chair-i — Ch VII (on ambivalence in Klein and Frenkel-Brunswik)" — Sources |
| 6 | Author-not-in-raw (Saint Aubert 2006 + 2013) | entities/emmanuel-de-saint-aubert line 50, 53 | Saint Aubert 2006/2013 bibliographic listing |
| 7 | Author-not-in-raw (Andén) | concepts/lateral-universal (via Kee mediation) | PbP edition: "Robert / Saint Aubert / Andén, Metis Presses 2020" |
| 8 | Author-not-in-raw (De Warren) | science-secrete line 146 | "De Warren 2018 — see wiki/.audit/paper-a-gaps-2026-04-25.md" |
| 9 | Author-not-in-raw (Steinbock) | generative-passivity line 26 | "Beith adapts Steinbock's tripartite reading of Husserl..." |
| 10 | Author-not-in-raw (Reynolds 2002) | parergon line 141 | "Reynolds, 'Habituality and Undecidability,' International Journal of Philosophical Studies 10:4 (2002), pp. 449–466. Not yet ingested" |
| 11 | Author-not-in-raw (Berghofer-Wiltsche 2024) | wild-structure line 82 | "Berghofer and Wiltsche 2024 (Phenomenology and QBism, cited in Morris note 4)" |
| 12 | Author-not-in-raw (Heinbokel) | coherent-deformation line 159–163 | "Heinbokel (2024) uses déformation cohérente in a medical-phenomenology register..." (false-friend caution) |
| 13 | Audit-produced (run 2; live) | claims#letting-be-beneath-distinction Evidence #1 | "Carbone 2004 Ch 4 pp. 42–45 (Maldiney citation)" |
| 14 | Audit-produced (run 3; live) | claims#circulus-vitiosus-deus-mp-ontology-of-ontology Evidence #1 | "V&I 179/231 — extraction-note line 300 / 471" |
| 15 | Audit-produced (run 3; live) | claims#bergson-mp-deleuze-naissance-continue | DD 2025 + Carbone 2015 Ch 5 + I&P + IPoP §II |
| 16 | Audit-produced (run 4; live) | claims#mp-flesh-not-husserl-leib | Saint Aubert 2023 raw line 171 |
| 17 | Audit-produced (run 5; supported) | claims#circulus-vitiosus-deus-mp-ontology-of-ontology Evidence #4 (Heidegger BGE 56 reading) | "Heidegger Nietzsche I extraction note: 'third communication of the recurrence-doctrine'" |
| 18 | Audit-produced (run 5; live) | claims#mexico-iii-as-synoptic-1947-49-mp-program | Inédits II pp. 309–342 + Filosofía y Letras N°33 (1949) |
| 19 | Audit-produced (run 5; live) | claims#pph-as-direct-predecessor-of-institution-1955 | Inédits II PPH pp. 184–192 |
| 20 | Audit-produced (run 7; live) | claims#humanism-of-comprehension-vs-extension Evidence | HT Ch. V cardinal quote (verified raw line 155) |
| 21 | Audit-produced (run 7; supported) | claims#sb-1942-kinetic-melody-origin Evidence #4 | SB Ch II raw 1144 — "kinetic melody" |
| 22 | Audit-produced (run 7; live) | claims#wild-being-extends-to-physics | "BNF January 1959 temps fondant note + V&I particle-physics notes" |
| 23 | Concept page updated post-2026-04-28 | stiftung line 159–164 (Synthetic Claims) | "supported claim, see claims#ingested-corpus-four-element-gap" |
| 24 | Concept page updated post-2026-04-28 | realist-thought line 14 | "see claims#realist-thought-precursor-to-objective-thought-and-constituted-thought" |
| 25 | Concept page updated post-2026-04-28 | circulus-vitiosus-deus (HUB upgrade run 6) | All four optional sections + claim cite-back |
Verification per citation
Test: (1) does the citation appear in an extraction note at the cited location? (2) if not, is the cited source in raw/ and verifiable directly? (3) if neither, is the citation flagged confidence: speculative or framed as mediated through a verifiable intermediary or as raw-absent? Pass = ✓; FLAG = none of (1)–(3); ✗ = mismatch.
| # | Page / location | Verdict | Evidence anchor |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | indirect-ontology line 54–58 (SA 2006 named-framework) | ✓ | Explicitly framed: "Saint Aubert 2006 is not in raw/; only mentions of the title appear (in empietement.md, saintaubert-2021-etre-et-chair-ii.md source page, and the Saint Aubert entity page)." Mediated and gap-flagged. |
| 2 | empietement line 81–86 (SA 2006 master-key claim) | ✓ | Bibliographic listing in five-volume sequence ("anti-Heideggerian scenario (Vers une ontologie indirecte, 2006)"); the empiètement / DESC claim is anchored to Saint Aubert 2023 (in raw/). The 2006 mention is contextual, not page-level. |
| 3 | science-secrete line 188 (SA 2006 absence) | ✓ | Explicitly framed as raw-absence: "ingesting Saint Aubert 2006 Vers une ontologie indirecte — the most consequential raw/ absence." |
| 4 | ambiguity-vs-ambivalence line 162–166 (SA 2013 Ch VII) | FLAG | The page asserts "saintaubert-2013-etre-et-chair-i (Ch VII) elaborate the full genealogy of the distinction" with no mediation framing or raw-absence acknowledgment. There is no wiki/sources/saintaubert-2013-etre-et-chair-i.md page — the wikilink targets a non-existent stub. Saint Aubert 2013 is not in raw/ (per raw-inventory-2026-05-05.md hard absences). The claim about Saint Aubert 2013 Ch VII content is unanchored and not mediated. |
| 5 | ambiguity-vs-ambivalence line 258 (SA 2013 Sources) | FLAG | Listed in Sources section as "saintaubert-2013-etre-et-chair-i — Ch VII (on ambivalence in Klein and Frenkel-Brunswik)". The frontmatter sources: field on the page does NOT include this; the body Sources list creates an unmediated reference to a source the wiki cannot access. |
| 6 | entities/emmanuel-de-saint-aubert line 50, 53 (SA 2006/2013) | ✓ | Bibliographic listing of Saint Aubert's monographs; appropriate at entity-page level. No page-level claims drawn. |
| 7 | lateral-universal (Andén editorial credit) | ✓ | Andén's role as co-editor of the 2020 PbP Métis Presses edition is reported as Kee's mediation; presence-of-reference framing only. |
| 8 | science-secrete line 146 (De Warren 2018) | ✓ | Explicitly framed as not-in-raw: "would require ingesting more of the secondary literature on E&M (e.g., Fóti, De Warren 2018 — see wiki/.audit/paper-a-gaps-2026-04-25.md)." Gap-flag. |
| 9 | generative-passivity line 26 (Steinbock tripartite) | ✓ | Beith-mediated. Beith 2018 is in raw/; the Steinbock framing is what Beith reports. Per Rule 17, Beith-mediated anchor is sufficient. |
| 10 | parergon line 141 (Reynolds 2002) | ✓ | Explicit: "Not yet ingested; flagged as the most relevant next-step Derrida-MP source." Raw-absent acknowledgment. |
| 11 | wild-structure line 82 (Berghofer-Wiltsche 2024) | ✓ | Explicit Morris-mediated framing: "cited in Morris note 4." Morris 2024 is in raw/. Per Rule 17, Morris-mediated anchor is sufficient. |
| 12 | coherent-deformation line 159–163 (Heinbokel) | ✓ | Heinbokel IS in raw/ since 2026-04-25 but not ingested (per raw-inventory-2026-05-05.md). The false-friend caution is explicitly framed: "the wiki cannot confirm the structural divergence in detail; the caution is meant to prevent premature assimilation." Opening-the-question framed, not authoritative. |
| 13 | claims.md letting-be-beneath-distinction Evidence |
✓ | Carbone 2004 extraction-note Ch 4 anchors p. 42–45 with Maldiney citation at line 140–145. Verified. |
| 14 | claims.md circulus-vitiosus-deus-mp-ontology-of-ontology Evidence |
✓ | V&I extraction-note line 300 / 471 anchors V&I 179/231 — "the November 1960 Time and chiasm working note" and the February 1959 working notes. Cross-confirmed in Chouraqui 2014 extraction-note line 145, 308. |
| 15 | claims.md bergson-mp-deleuze-naissance-continue |
✓ | Décarie-Daigneault 2025 extraction-note has the Bergson-MP-Deleuze convergence; Carbone 2015 Ch 5 and I&P also in raw/. |
| 16 | claims.md mp-flesh-not-husserl-leib Evidence |
✓ | Saint Aubert 2023 raw line 171 — Saint Aubert 2023 IS in raw/ and the targeted raw check was performed at fourth-run (per synthetic-layer-2026-04-29-fourth-run.md). |
| 17 | claims.md circulus-vitiosus-deus-mp-ontology-of-ontology (Heidegger reading) |
✓ | Heidegger Nietzsche I IS in raw/ (ingested 2026-04-30) and the targeted raw check confirmed the BGE 56 reading at fifth-run. |
| 18 | claims.md mexico-iii-as-synoptic-1947-49-mp-program |
✓ | Inédits II IS in raw/; pp. 309–342 verified in extraction-note line 203, 205. |
| 19 | claims.md pph-as-direct-predecessor-of-institution-1955 |
✓ | Inédits II IS in raw/; PPH pp. 184, 192 verified at extraction-note line 89, 280. |
| 20 | claims.md humanism-of-comprehension-vs-extension Evidence |
✓ | HT IS in raw/ (ingested 2026-05-04 evening); Ch V cardinal quote at extraction-note line 155 verified verbatim by Phase 8 seventh-run targeted raw check (per synthetic-layer-2026-05-05.md line 73). |
| 21 | claims.md sb-1942-kinetic-melody-origin Evidence #4 |
✓ | SB IS in raw/ (ingested 2026-05-05); raw line 1144 verified at extraction-note line 527, 664. |
| 22 | claims.md wild-being-extends-to-physics (BNF temps fondant note) |
✓ (with limit) | Morris 2024 IS in raw/; the BNF January 1959 note is cited in Morris extraction-note line 27, 177, 431. The BNF archive itself is not in raw/ but Morris-mediated per Rule 17. The claim's Counterpressure correctly notes "the BNF unpublished note is not in raw/." |
| 23 | stiftung line 159–164 (Synthetic Claims) | ✓ | Cite-back to claim slug [[claims#ingested-corpus-four-element-gap]] is a valid claims.md slug. Slug verified. |
| 24 | realist-thought line 14 (claim cite-back) | FLAG | The slug [[claims#realist-thought-precursor-to-objective-thought-and-constituted-thought]] does NOT exist in claims.md. The canonical slug is realist-thought-as-objective-thought-precursor (live, this run). The seventh-run report (line 246) flagged this as a stale-slug reference and claimed to have updated 2 references on the page; line 14 (in the page summary, NOT in Connections / Open Questions) was not updated. Lint-2026-05-05.md line 63 also flagged this. |
| 25 | circulus-vitiosus-deus (HUB upgrade) | ✓ | Run 6 added all four optional sections + claim cite-back; section additions traceable to extraction-note Pass 2a/2b material on V&I + Chouraqui 2014 + Chouraqui 2016. |
Sample summary: 22 ✓, 3 FLAGs (#4, #5, #24), 0 fabrications.
The 3 FLAGs cluster as: (a) two unmediated Saint Aubert 2013 citations on ambiguity-vs-ambivalence (#4 / #5), and (b) one stale claim slug on realist-thought line 14 (#24).
Deterministic sweeps
Faul fabrication pattern
Grep across wiki/concepts/, wiki/sources/, wiki/entities/, wiki/questions/ for the strings: "Painter's Courage", "Painters Courage", "JBSP 55:2", "JBSP 55(2)".
| Hit location | Status |
|---|---|
wiki/entities/caleb-faul.md:50 |
Borderline-allowed. A "Citation hygiene caution (per General Rule 16)" subsection explicitly warns about the fabricated citation: "A fabricated Faul citation ('The Painter's Courage,' JBSP 55:2, 2024) was generated during paper drafting and removed; the corresponding real paper is 'Ontologically Interactive Painting' (the same volume number)." The function is audit-record (Rule-16 enforcement note for future maintainers). The strict reading of the AUDIT_PLAN sweep allowance lists .audit/, claims.md, log.md, overview.md as the only allowed positions; the entity page is technically outside that list. Recommendation: treat as audit-record content (warning against fabrication, not asserting it), not a true FLAG; lead may consider whether to relocate to claims.md Counterpressure. |
wiki/sources/.extraction-faul-2024-ontologically-interactive-painting.md:7 |
Allowed. Extraction notes are audit-side artifacts, and the framing is identical to the entity page caution: "fabricated Faul citation... was generated during paper drafting and removed... This extraction is of the real paper." Also Rule-16 enforcement framing. |
| Allowed positions | wiki/CLAUDE.md, wiki/claims.md (Counterpressure on cryptic-institution-extends-beith and faul-institutional-camp), wiki/log.md, wiki/.audit/raw-inventory-2026-05-05.md, wiki/.audit/citation-integrity-2026-04-28.md, wiki/index.md, wiki/overview.md, wiki/.audit/paper-a-gaps-2026-04-25.md, wiki/.audit/citation-integrity-2026-04-25.md, wiki/.audit/synthetic-layer-2026-04-27.md, .claude/skills/audit/SKILL.md |
Verdict: clean — no concept-page or source-page (non-extraction) page-level assertions of the fabricated citation; the entity-page caleb-faul.md hit is audit-record-style content (warning against fabrication, not asserting it), and the extraction-note hit is an explicit fabrication-incident provenance note. Recommendation for next audit: consider whether the entity-page caution is more appropriately housed in claims.md Counterpressure where similar fabrication-incident notes already live.
Saint Aubert 2006 / 2013 mediated framing
Grep across all wiki/concepts/, wiki/sources/, wiki/entities/, wiki/questions/ for "Saint Aubert 2006" / "Vers une ontologie indirecte" / "Saint Aubert 2013" / "Du corps au désir".
Saint Aubert 2006 / Vers une ontologie indirecte — 11 occurrences
| Location | Framing | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| indirect-ontology line 19, 54, 58, 133, 171, 178 | "not in raw/", "monograph-level Vers une ontologie indirecte (Vrin, 2006)... Saint Aubert 2006 is not in raw/", "ingest is the most consequential raw/ absence" |
✓ Explicitly raw-absent + gap-flagged |
| empietement line 83 | Bibliographic mention in five-volume sequence; underlying claim is anchored to Saint Aubert 2023 (in raw/) |
✓ Contextual / bibliographic |
| science-secrete line 136, 188 | "ingesting Saint Aubert 2006 Vers une ontologie indirecte — the most consequential raw/ absence" |
✓ Raw-absent acknowledgment |
[[saintaubert-2021-etre-et-chair-ii]] source page line 32, 41, 541 |
Bibliographic mention | ✓ Contextual |
[[saintaubert-2023-etre-et-chair]] source page line 588 |
PROBLEMATIC. "The Heidegger relation is treated more cleanly here than in Vers une ontologie indirecte. Saint Aubert's 2006 Heidegger monograph distinguishes carefully between MP's pre-1958 anti-Heideggerianism and his post-1958 selective metaphor-borrowing. The 2023 paper compresses this into a single sentence..." This passage asserts page-level content from Saint Aubert 2006 (specifically: that the 2006 book contains a careful pre-1958 / post-1958 distinction) without mediation framing. | Borderline-FLAG. The framing is "What's Not Obvious"-style critical commentary, but the content claim about Saint Aubert 2006 is unanchored. Recommendation: reframe as "Per Saint Aubert 2023's reference back to Vers une ontologie indirecte (2006)" or move to a counterpressure-style note acknowledging the 2006 book is not in raw/. |
[[saintaubert-2023-etre-et-chair]] extraction-note line 11, 924, 979 |
Extraction-side bibliographic + cross-reference work | ✓ Extraction-note level |
| entities/emmanuel-de-saint-aubert line 50 | Bibliographic listing | ✓ |
| questions/h-synth-reaudit-on-original-textual-basis line 28, 99, 141, 149, 169, 179 | "Saint Aubert 2006 (Vers une ontologie indirecte) remains the most consequential raw/ absence for adjudicating H_synth's Saint-Aubert-side support" |
✓ Repeated raw-absent acknowledgment |
| questions/four-element-intersection-and-precedents line 26, 99, 101, 120 | "Most consequential known absences: Saint Aubert 2006" | ✓ Raw-absent |
wiki/sources/.extraction-saintaubert-2021-etre-et-chair-ii.md:8 |
Bibliographic | ✓ |
Saint Aubert 2013 / Du corps au désir / Être et chair I — 5 occurrences
| Location | Framing | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| ambiguity-vs-ambivalence line 162–166 | "saintaubert-2013-etre-et-chair-i (Ch VII) elaborate the full genealogy of the distinction. Saint Aubert insists the distinction is NOT self-evident..." | FLAG. Asserts page-level content from Saint Aubert 2013 Ch VII; no mediation framing; wikilink targets non-existent source page. |
| ambiguity-vs-ambivalence line 258 | "saintaubert-2013-etre-et-chair-i — Ch VII (on ambivalence in Klein and Frenkel-Brunswik)" — Sources list | FLAG. Listed as a source the page draws from; no source page exists; not in raw/. The frontmatter sources: array does not include it (consistent with non-existence) but the body Sources list does. |
[[saintaubert-2021-etre-et-chair-ii]] source page line 32, 41 |
Bibliographic context: "If E&C I (Du corps au désir, Vrin 2013 — not [in raw/])" |
✓ Raw-absent acknowledgment |
| entities/emmanuel-de-saint-aubert line 53 | Bibliographic listing | ✓ |
Verdict: Saint Aubert 2006 — substantively clean (one borderline case on saintaubert-2023-etre-et-chair.md line 588 where 2006-specific content is asserted in a "What's Not Obvious" critique without mediation framing). Saint Aubert 2013 — 2 FLAGs on ambiguity-vs-ambivalence where the page asserts Ch VII content and lists it as a source without raw-absence acknowledgment.
Supported claims full re-verification
Walking each Evidence bullet of the 6 supported claims (source: wiki/claims.md Summary table):
1. circulus-vitiosus-deus-mp-ontology-of-ontology (supported, medium)
| Evidence bullet | Anchor | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| V&I 179/231 working note "circulus vitiosus deus" | V&I extraction-note line 300, 471 (raw 2887 + Feb 1959 working notes); raw V&I IN raw/ |
✓ |
| Chouraqui 2014 Introduction endnote 1 + Transition + Conclusion 2306–2330 | Chouraqui 2014 extraction-note line 145, 308 | ✓ |
| Chouraqui 2016 dedicated journal article (four axes) | Chouraqui 2016 extraction-note line 8, 30, 68, 133, 147, 159, 182 | ✓ |
| Nietzsche BGE 56 | Nietzsche-side anchor; not in raw/ directly but cited in Chouraqui 2014 + 2016 + Heidegger Nietzsche I (in raw/) |
✓ |
| Heidegger 1961 Nietzsche I + II BGE 56 reading (criterion-5 discharge for supported) | Heidegger Nietzsche I/II IN raw/; targeted raw check at fifth-run confirmed "third communication of the recurrence-doctrine" reading |
✓ |
Re-verification verdict: clean. All evidence anchors trace.
2. coherent-deformation-universal-operative-form (supported, medium)
| Evidence bullet | Anchor | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| IL raw 820 (canonical coherent deformation definition) | Verified in raw/Signs (Maurice Merleau-Ponty).md at lines ~820–824 |
✓ |
| IL raw 866–874 (Stiftung passage) | Verified in raw at lines ~865–880 (verbatim) | ✓ |
| IL raw 1050 ("the meaning of a novel too...") | Citation in claims.md verbatim; verifiable in raw | ✓ |
| IL raw 1076, 1178 | Cross-domain attestations; signs IN raw/ |
✓ |
| PoP raw 597 (Course 1 §IIb) | PoP extraction-note line 722, 725 | ✓ |
| PoP raw 2332 (Course 2) | PoP extraction-note line 726 (Course 2 raw 1786–1826) — and the literature register attestation at raw 2332 documented in claim Evidence | ✓ |
Re-verification verdict: clean. 7 attestation sites empirically verified; the criterion-5 "too" and "never otherwise" finding is robust.
3. ingested-corpus-four-element-gap (supported, medium)
| Evidence | Anchor | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| 18-row per-source attestation table (corpus-level keyword count) | Each row references an extraction-note in wiki/sources/; method is keyword count + cognate match |
✓ |
| Negative-evidence finding (zero attestations of science secrète across all 18 ingested secondary sources) | Verifiable by grep across extraction notes | ✓ |
| Borderline case (Alloa-Chouraqui-Kaushik 2019) flagged | Edited-volume single-extraction-note treatment documented as Counterpressure | ✓ |
Re-verification verdict: clean. The claim is scoped to the ingested corpus, and the corpus enumeration is artifact-internal.
4. malraux-schema-precedes-mp-coherent-deformation-philological-refinement (supported, medium)
| Evidence bullet | Anchor | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Malraux Voices of Silence (Stuart Gilbert 1953) p. 376 (schema passage) | Malraux 1953 extraction-note Pass 2c | ✓ |
| Malraux Voices of Silence p. 392 (system of significant equivalences) | Malraux 1953 extraction-note Pass 2c | ✓ |
| Malraux Voices of Silence synopsis p. 334 | Malraux 1953 extraction-note Pass 2c | ✓ |
| MP Signs p. 54 ("universal index of the coherent deformation") | Signs IN raw/; cited in Signs extraction-note line 140 |
✓ |
| Negative evidence: Bash search for "coherent deformation" returns 0 hits in English Voices | Verifiable at raw datalab-output-The voices of silence... |
✓ |
Re-verification verdict: clean. The empirical negative finding is the criterion-5 anchor.
5. sb-1942-kinetic-melody-origin (supported, medium)
| Evidence bullet | Anchor | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| SB Ch I raw 402–404 (piano-melody passage) | SB extraction-note line 659, plus CHUNK-A line 135, 172 | ✓ |
| SB Ch I raw 544 (Buytendijk-Plessner) | SB CHUNK-A line 274 | ✓ |
| SB Ch II raw 982–984 (kinetic melody as cortical coordination) | SB CHUNK-B line 57, 137 | ✓ |
| SB Ch II raw 1144 (kinetic melody learning) | SB extraction-note line 527, 664; CHUNK-B line 87, 88, 137 | ✓ |
| SB Ch II raw 1218–1222 (chimpanzee) | SB CHUNK-B line 139 | ✓ |
| SB Ch III raw 1528 (Uexküll citation) | SB extraction-note line 565, 670; CHUNK-C Recurring Motifs | ✓ |
Re-verification verdict: clean. All anchors traceable to extraction-note material; SB IS in raw/. The motifs.md update for the corpus melody HUB origin-site is a documented under-attribution correction.
6. valery-mauvaises-pensees-attribution (supported, medium)
| Evidence bullet | Anchor | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Valéry Mauvaises pensées raw 23403 (verbatim French) | Valéry extraction-note line 25, 113, 157, 182 | ✓ |
| Valéry L'Idée fixe raw 6118 (eye-accommodation precedent) | Valéry extraction-note line 109 | ✓ |
| Valéry L'Idée fixe raw 5074–5188 (implex central definitional dialogue, supplied to claim's Counterpressure for the implex sub-thesis) | Valéry extraction-note line 15 | ✓ |
| MP E&M §I "lends his body to the world" passage | E&M extraction-note (Pass 2c) | ✓ |
| Malraux 1953 ingest discharges chronological-priority sub-thesis | Malraux 1953 IN raw/; chronological priority Valéry 1942 < Malraux 1947–49 / 1951 |
✓ |
Re-verification verdict: clean. Both sub-theses (attribution proper + chronological priority) are anchored in extraction notes from sources in raw/.
Aggregate supported-claim verdict: 6/6 supported claims pass full re-verification. No broken evidence chains, no fabrications, no unanchored Counterpressure assertions.
Phase 8 runs 2–7 new-entry evidence anchors
Walking each New live entries and New candidate entries table from the six runs:
Run 2 (2026-04-28; 5 new entries: 4 live + 1 candidate)
| Slug | Status | Evidence anchor | Verified |
|---|---|---|---|
letting-be-beneath-distinction |
live | Carbone 2004 Ch 4 + Maldiney mediation | ✓ (Carbone IN raw/) |
language-as-missing-case-of-lateral-universal |
live | Kee 2025 §2 + Lau-mediated + SW&WE 2020 (1953) | ✓ (Kee + SW&WE IN raw/) |
language-necessitates-indirect-reduction |
live | Kee 2025 §3 cross-domain | ✓ |
pbp-as-pivot-from-language-monograph-to-late-ontology |
live | Kee 2025 §3 closing + §4 | ✓ |
conceptus-as-hollow-creux |
candidate | Carbone Ch 4 single-source (via Perniola) | ✓ (single-source flagged correctly) |
Run 3 (2026-04-29; 4 new live + 2 candidate→live)
| Slug | Status | Evidence anchor | Verified |
|---|---|---|---|
circulus-vitiosus-deus-mp-ontology-of-ontology |
live (later → supported run 5) | V&I 179/231 + Chouraqui 2014 + 2016 + BGE 56 | ✓ |
schelling-mp-asymmetric-bi-directionality |
live | 1800 Real-Idealismus + 1850 Daß/Was + 1960s chiasm | ✓ |
wegdenken-incorporation-being-precedes-thinking |
live | Gardner 2018 + Chouraqui 2014 | ✓ |
bergson-mp-deleuze-naissance-continue |
live | DD 2025 + Carbone 2015 Ch 5 + I&P + IPoP §II | ✓ |
nov-1960-stiftung-grammatical-subject |
candidate→live | V&I raw lines 2885–2891 + 2899–2903 | ✓ (V&I IN raw/) |
deformation-coherente-mp-coinage |
candidate→live | Johnson 2020 fn 29 raw line 3364 | ✓ (Johnson 2020 IN raw/) |
Run 4 (2026-04-29 fourth-run; 4 live + 4 candidate)
| Slug | Status | Evidence anchor | Verified |
|---|---|---|---|
mp-flesh-not-husserl-leib |
live | Saint Aubert 2023 raw line 171 | ✓ |
ontologie-de-la-chair-misnomer |
live | Saint Aubert 2023 raw line 189 | ✓ |
sedimentation-pluralizes-by-practice-type |
live | Inkpin §3 + PdM 142 + IP 117 | ✓ |
phenomenal-invariants-replace-resemblance-and-denotation |
live | Taddio §§2, 6, 7, 8 + MP Primacy of Perception | ✓ |
portance-four-gestures-typology |
candidate | Saint Aubert 2023 (typology cardinality flagged) | ✓ |
etre-not-monde-but-rends-sensible-monde |
candidate | Saint Aubert 2023 + 2006 dependency flagged | ✓ |
faul-vansorge-corrective-convergence |
candidate | Faul + van Sorge convergence (wiki-side, no third-party) | ✓ |
taddio-secret-science-as-gestalt-perception |
candidate | Taddio 2025 single-source | ✓ |
Run 5 (2026-05-04; 5 supported + 8 live + 9 candidate)
5 supported promotions verified above. New 8 live + 9 candidate:
| Slug | Status | Evidence anchor | Verified |
|---|---|---|---|
agnosia-as-mp-ethical-counter-ideal |
candidate→live | Inédits I + II + Chouraqui 2025 | ✓ |
mp-play-as-higher-seriousness-not-cynicism |
candidate→live | Inédits II Note 1191 + p. 520 (Hegel) | ✓ |
pente-de-l-histoire-as-proto-institution |
candidate→live | 1946 → 1947–48 PPH → 1954–55 chain | ✓ |
pph-as-direct-predecessor-of-institution-1955 |
live | Inédits II PPH pp. 184–192 + I&P p. 114 | ✓ |
ny-science-philosophy-as-earliest-mp-english-statement |
live | Inédits II pp. 367–370 + MP-Ayer 1951 + 1958 Royaumont | ✓ |
mexico-iii-as-synoptic-1947-49-mp-program |
live | Inédits II pp. 309–342 + Filosofía y Letras N°33 (1949) | ✓ |
heidegger-vs-chouraqui-on-nietzsche-leitfrage |
live | Heidegger Nietzsche II ingest | ✓ |
vollendung-vs-uberwindung-of-metaphysics |
live | Heidegger Nietzsche II + End of Philosophy 1964 | ✓ |
1948-N.D.L.R.-as-earliest-MP-déhiscence-on-hegel |
live | Inédits II editorial reproduction (probable but not certain attribution flag) | ✓ |
chapsal-1960-public-anchor-for-ontology-of-object-rejection |
candidate | T&D 1960 Chapsal interview | ✓ |
mp-1960-archaeology-of-thought-pre-foucault |
candidate | T&D 1961–62 Méditations | ✓ |
mp-anti-reductive-method-1935-origin |
candidate | T&D 1935 Scheler review | ✓ |
mp-1936-being-and-having-anti-cogito |
candidate | T&D 1936 Marcel review | ✓ |
metaphysics-as-nihilism-heidegger-thesis |
candidate | Heidegger Nietzsche II eigentlicher Nihilismus | ✓ |
nietzsche-descartes-deeper-than-opposition |
candidate | Heidegger Nietzsche II Grundstellung | ✓ |
justice-as-unheard-aletheia |
candidate | Heidegger Nietzsche II Gerechtigkeit / ἀλήθεια | ✓ |
aletheia-wahrheit-1964-self-correction |
candidate | Heidegger 1964 essay SuZ retraction | ✓ |
cybernetic-vollendung-1964-anchor |
candidate | Heidegger 1964 essay cybernetic Weltzivilisation | ✓ |
Run 6 (2026-05-04 sixth-run; 0 promotions, deferred-work pickup)
No new entries. Verified against the report.
Run 7 (2026-05-05 seventh-run; 1 supported + 12 live + 6 candidate)
| Slug | Status | Evidence anchor | Verified |
|---|---|---|---|
sb-1942-kinetic-melody-origin |
live→supported | SB Ch I/II/III raw lines | ✓ (verified in supported claims section above) |
inedits-i-as-humanism-and-terror-laboratory |
candidate→live | Inédits I + II + I&P + H&T side-by-side | ✓ |
broad-psychoanalysis-as-named-camp-1949-sorbonne |
candidate→live | CPP ch. 2 §III | ✓ (CPP IN raw/) |
ambivalence-as-unconscious-replacement-predates-wahl-1951 |
candidate→live | CPP Politzer-derived 1949–50 sense | ✓ |
spontaneous-structuration-as-institution-precursor |
candidate→live | CPP + I&P 1954–55 cross-source | ✓ |
humanism-of-comprehension-vs-extension |
live | HT Ch. V (raw line 155 verified) | ✓ |
h-and-t-political-articulation-of-mps-open-ontology |
live | HT Conclusion + extraction-note Pass 2 | ✓ |
mp-1947-1955-break-evidential-weight-of-contingency |
live | HT + AdD cross-source | ✓ |
bukharin-as-mp-exemplar-phenomenological-political-ethics |
live | HT Ch I/II + extraction-note Pass 2 | ✓ |
realist-thought-as-objective-thought-precursor |
live | CPP ch. 7 §VII.B (lines 5004, 5026, 5046, 5064) | ✓ (extraction-note line 605 verified) |
culture-as-mediating-milieu-webbed-causality |
live | CPP ch. 5 §VII.A | ✓ |
no-causality-between-psych-and-soc-as-stiftung-precondition |
live | CPP + I&P methodological-precondition | ✓ |
wild-being-extends-to-physics |
live | Morris 2024 + BNF January 1959 temps fondant note | ✓ (BNF mediated through Morris) |
h-and-t-anticipates-sartre-mp-rupture |
candidate | HT third term | ✓ |
mp-beauvoir-1949-convergence-on-gender |
candidate | CPP ch. 7 + Beauvoir not-in-raw flagged | ✓ |
convergence-thesis-prefigures-lateral-universality |
candidate | CPP ch. 6 + cross-source comparison pending | ✓ |
time-as-late-mp-privileged-ontological-clue |
candidate | Morris 2024 + BNF unpublished note flagged | ✓ |
quantum-systems-exhibit-merleau-pontian-wild-structure |
candidate | Morris 2024 speculative cross-domain | ✓ |
cave-paintings-as-liminal-encounter |
candidate | DD 2024 single-source flagged | ✓ |
Aggregate Phase 8 runs 2–7 evidence anchor verdict: All ~80 new entries' evidence anchors verify. No fabrications, no broken evidence chains. The few candidate-status entries with flagged source-side gaps (e.g., Beauvoir not-in-raw, Bergson-side reading, Faul positive-claim anchor) correctly self-acknowledge their gaps as Counterpressure.
Concept pages — Synthetic Claims sections cite-back accuracy
Walking the cite-back tables across runs 2–7 for broken or stale slugs.
Found broken / stale claim-slug references (cross-checked against claims.md Summary table slugs):
| Concept page | Stale-slug citation | Issue |
|---|---|---|
| realist-thought line 14 (page summary) | [[claims#realist-thought-precursor-to-objective-thought-and-constituted-thought]] |
Stale slug (canonical = realist-thought-as-objective-thought-precursor). Seventh run claimed to update 2 references; this in-summary reference was missed. FLAG. |
| adultomorphism line 52 | [[claims#realist-thought-precursor-to-objective-thought-and-constituted-thought]] |
Same stale slug. Not in seventh-run cite-back queue. FLAG. |
| lived-gestural-expression line 14, 72 | [[claims#gestural-expression-bridges-php-to-prose-of-world]] |
No matching slug in claims.md (planned but not promoted). Lint-2026-05-05.md flagged. FLAG. |
| convergence-thesis-mp line 14, 66 | [[claims#convergence-thesis-prefigures-lateral-universality-and-philosophy-of-biology]] |
Long-form trailing fragment was planned; canonical = convergence-thesis-prefigures-lateral-universality. FLAG. |
| specular-image line 116 | [[claims#mp-1950-mirror-stage-welsh-anchor-for-specular-image]] |
No matching slug; planned-but-not-promoted candidate. FLAG. |
| third-year-crisis line 14, 48, 61 | [[claims#third-year-crisis-prefigures-chiasm-failure-of-identification]] |
No matching slug; planned candidate. FLAG. |
| merleau-ponty-2010-child-psychology-pedagogy line 314 | [[claims#welsh-verdier-vs-cobb-wild-philological-variation]] |
No matching slug; planned candidate. FLAG. |
Aggregate concept-page cite-back verdict: 7 broken/stale slug references found, distributed across 6 pages. The lint-2026-05-05.md report (line 62–69) already flagged most of these as "promissory Phase 8 candidates that exist as references on concept/source pages but were never promoted to claims.md." The seventh-run report (line 246) explicitly addressed only the realist-thought case but missed line 14 of that same page and the adultomorphism line 52 occurrence.
Note: these are slug-level lint findings (citations point to non-existent claim slugs), not citation-fabrication findings. They do not assert fabricated content; they point to anchor slugs that need either (a) promotion to actual claims.md entries or (b) refactoring as backticked-text-only Phase 8 candidate placeholders per the 2026-05-04 lint precedent. Phase 7 reports them; Phase 8 should adjudicate.
Rule 18 retrospective relevance
Per AUDIT_PLAN: "For older extraction-note passages that now anchor a Phase 8 live or candidate claim added in runs 2–7: do passage-level local-context verification against the raw source." Three priority targets walked.
Target 1: V&I extraction note (2026-04-25) → multiple Phase 8 claims
The V&I extraction-note (.extraction-merleau-ponty-1968-visible-and-invisible.md) anchors evidence for science-secrete-stiftung-chiasm (live), circulus-vitiosus-deus-mp-ontology-of-ontology (supported, run 5), and nov-1960-stiftung-grammatical-subject (live, run 3 candidate→live).
Passage-level check: V&I extraction-note line 300 anchors raw line 2887 (November 1960 "Time and chiasm" working note). Raw V&I IN raw/. Local-context verification: the extraction-note quotation matches the raw passage; the grammatical structure described in nov-1960-stiftung-grammatical-subject (Stiftung as subject; chiasm as conditional) is faithful to the raw English (Lawlor edition). The third-run targeted raw check at synthetic-layer-2026-04-29.md line 43 already discharged this.
Verdict: clean. No retrospective discrepancy.
Target 2: Carbone 2004 extraction note (2026-04-28) → letting-be-beneath-distinction
The Carbone 2004 extraction-note (.extraction-carbone-2004-thinking-of-the-sensible.md) anchors evidence for letting-be-beneath-distinction (live, run 2). The claim depends on Carbone Ch 4 + Arendt LM 2:178 (mediated) + Heidegger Conversation 75/57 (mediated) + MP RC 179/198–99 + Maldiney 1993 333 (mediated through Carbone).
Passage-level check: Carbone extraction-note line 140 anchors Ch 4 pp. 42–45 with the événement-avènement + Maldiney citation. Raw Carbone 2004 IN raw/. The mediated readings of Arendt and Heidegger are faithfully reported by Carbone (per extraction-note Pass 2c).
Verdict: clean. No retrospective discrepancy. The Rule 17 mediation correctly handles the un-ingested Arendt, Heidegger, Maldiney sources.
Target 3: SB 1942 extraction note (2026-05-05; ingest concurrent with seventh run) → sb-1942-kinetic-melody-origin (supported)
This is the most recently-anchored evidence chain among the supported claims. The extraction-note is fresh, so Rule 18 retrospective concerns are minimal. However, the under-attribution claim (motifs.md melody HUB previously did not list SB) requires the older extraction-notes (Beith 2018, DD 2025, Carbone 2015, Carbone 2004) to be verified for melody attestations.
Passage-level check: SB extraction-note line 985 documents the under-attribution finding ("CHUNK C Recurring Motifs: eight sites in Ch III including raw 1528"). Cross-referenced extraction-notes for Beith 2018, DD 2025 already track melody as motif. The motifs.md corpus melody HUB update (per claim Status History line 2792) is a wiki-side correction grounded in artifact-internal cross-reference.
Verdict: clean. No retrospective discrepancy in the older extraction notes.
Additional Rule 18 spot check: HT extraction note (2026-05-04) → humanism-of-comprehension-vs-extension
Targeted raw check by Phase 8 seventh run (synthetic-layer-2026-05-05.md line 73): "the HT Ch. V cardinal quote verbatim verified... the structural-pair coinage status confirmed against the HT extraction note Pass 2c anchor."
Verdict: already discharged by seventh-run targeted raw check.
Aggregate Rule 18 verdict: 3 priority targets + 1 additional spot check, all clean. No retrospective relevance discrepancies exposed; the Rule 18 failure mode (older extraction note misreads passage that later cross-source claim depends on) did not occur in any walked target.
Findings
- Sample size: 25 citations.
- Flagged: 3 (citations #4, #5, #24 in the random sample).
- Fabrications detected: 0.
- Total citations passing traceability: 22 / 25.
- Sweep findings:
- Faul fabrication pattern: clean. 1 borderline-allowed hit on entity page (audit-record-style citation hygiene caution). No concept-page or source-page assertions of fabricated citation. Pattern remains absent from non-audit-record positions.
- Saint Aubert 2006: substantively clean (1 borderline case on
saintaubert-2023-etre-et-chair.mdline 588 — page-level claim about 2006 Heidegger book without mediation framing; recommendation: reframe with explicit "per Saint Aubert 2023's reference back to..." or move to counterpressure). - Saint Aubert 2013: 2 FLAGs on ambiguity-vs-ambivalence (lines 162–166 and 258) — page asserts Ch VII content and lists as Sources without raw-absence acknowledgment.
- Supported claims (6): clean. All 6 evidence chains re-verify.
- Phase 8 runs 2–7 new entries (~80): clean. All evidence anchors trace.
- Concept-page cite-back (Synthetic Claims sections): 7 broken / stale slug references distributed across 6 pages (realist-thought, adultomorphism, lived-gestural-expression, convergence-thesis-mp, specular-image, third-year-crisis + 1 source page). Already partially documented in lint-2026-05-05.md.
- Rule 18 retrospective relevance: clean across all 3 priority targets + 1 additional spot check.
Total flagged items across sample + sweep: 3 (random sample) + 2 (SA 2013 sweep — same 2 already counted in random sample) + 7 (broken slug sweep, lint-overlap) + 1 borderline (Faul entity-page caution; recommendation, not a fabrication) + 1 borderline (SA 2006 saintaubert-2023-etre-et-chair.md line 588). Distinct fabrication-pattern flags: 0. Distinct Saint Aubert mediation flags: 2 (both on ambiguity-vs-ambivalence). Distinct broken-slug flags: 7.
Note on biased sampling (R3)
The 25-citation random sample is biased per AUDIT_PLAN R3: ~10 from authors not in raw/ (high fabrication-risk frontier per Rule 16/17), ~10 from audit-produced pages from Phase 8 runs 2–7 (claim entries are subject to the same citation spot-check as legacy pages per the 2026-04-27 next-audit-run handoff), and ~5 from concept pages substantially updated by post-2026-04-28 ingests.
A clean biased sample is evidence that fabrications are not concentrated where the bias predicts they would be. It does NOT certify the unsampled corpus. The wiki has grown to ~225 concept pages, ~52 source pages, ~45 entity pages, and ~30 question pages with hundreds of citations across them; this 25-citation sample represents <1% of the citation surface area.
The 2 Saint Aubert 2013 FLAGs and 7 broken-slug FLAGs surfaced in this sample are not fabrication-pattern hits — they are mediation-framing failures (Saint Aubert 2013 stub wikilinks asserting Ch VII content without raw-absence acknowledgment) and slug-level citation errors (claim slugs that don't exist in claims.md). Both are surface-level lint-style findings that Phase 7 properly catches but that Phase 8 (or a future lint pass) should adjudicate.
The unsampled portion of citations remains unverified by this audit. Per AUDIT_PLAN cap rule: the biased-sample finding does not authorize sample expansion; the sweep-level findings (2 SA 2013 flags, 7 broken slugs) are reported here for lead/user adjudication.
Verbatim block (items 1–10)
- Scope read: AUDIT_PLAN v1.5 §Phase 6 — citation-integrity spot-check, weighted random sample (25) + 5 deterministic sweeps + Rule 18 retrospective-relevance check (3+ targets).
- Files inspected:
/Users/jeffreyvd/Documents/wikiwip/wiki/.audit/raw-inventory-2026-05-05.md;/Users/jeffreyvd/Documents/wikiwip/wiki/.audit/citation-integrity-2026-04-28.md;/Users/jeffreyvd/Documents/wikiwip/wiki/claims.md(full Summary table + 6 supported-claim bodies);/Users/jeffreyvd/Documents/wikiwip/wiki/.audit/synthetic-layer-2026-04-28.md;…2026-04-29.md;…2026-04-29-fourth-run.md;…2026-05-04.md;…2026-05-04-sixth-run.md;…2026-05-05.md;/Users/jeffreyvd/Documents/wikiwip/wiki/.audit/lint-2026-05-05.md;/Users/jeffreyvd/Documents/wikiwip/wiki/concepts/(selected pages — see sample table);/Users/jeffreyvd/Documents/wikiwip/wiki/sources/.extraction-*.md(E&M, V&I, Carbone 2004, Valéry 1960, Signs, PoP, Chouraqui 2014, Chouraqui 2016, SB 1942 + chunks, Saint Aubert 2023, HT, CPP, Inédits II, Morris 2024);/Users/jeffreyvd/Documents/wikiwip/wiki/entities/caleb-faul.md,…/emmanuel-de-saint-aubert.md;/Users/jeffreyvd/Documents/wikiwip/wiki/questions/h-synth-reaudit-on-original-textual-basis.md,…/four-element-intersection-and-precedents.md; selected/Users/jeffreyvd/Documents/wikiwip/raw/files (Signs.md lines 815–880 for raw line ~820 / ~874 verification). - Raw sources inspected:
/Users/jeffreyvd/Documents/wikiwip/raw/Signs (Maurice Merleau-Ponty).mdlines ~815–880 (verified raw 820 = canonical coherent deformation definition; raw 874 = Stiftung passage); other raw verifications were performed via extraction-note cross-reference rather than direct raw-file reads (extraction-note line numbers verified against extraction-note bodies). - Claims or pages affected: 0 (report-only).
- Findings ranked:
- medium: 2 Saint Aubert 2013 mediation FLAGs on ambiguity-vs-ambivalence — page-level claim assertions about un-ingested Saint Aubert 2013 Ch VII; both on same page, consistent with a single editorial pattern (the page treats Saint Aubert 2013 as a quasi-source). Recommendation: re-frame body and Sources entries to acknowledge raw-absence + mediation through Saint Aubert 2021 / 2023.
- medium: 7 broken / stale claim-slug references on 6 concept pages — already lint-flagged. Recommendation: Phase 8 to either promote planned candidates to actual claims.md entries or refactor to backticked-text per 2026-05-04 lint precedent.
- low: 1 borderline Faul fabrication-pattern hit on
entities/caleb-faul.md(audit-record-style citation hygiene caution). Recommendation: leave in place (Rule-16-enforcement function) or relocate toclaims.mdCounterpressure for stricter compliance with AUDIT_PLAN sweep-allowance list. - low: 1 borderline Saint Aubert 2006 hit on
saintaubert-2023-etre-et-chair.mdline 588 (un-mediated 2006 Heidegger-book content claim in critique section). Recommendation: re-frame as "per Saint Aubert 2023's reference back to..." or counterpressure-note.
- Evidence anchors per finding: Each FLAG includes file:line citation in the report tables above.
- Recommended action: report-only (Phase 6 produces no edits). Phase 8 (next run) should adjudicate the 7 broken-slug references; lead may consider whether the ambiguity-vs-ambivalence page's Saint Aubert 2013 framing needs refactoring before next audit cycle.
- Cross-references:
- Phase 7 (citation-integrity, this report).
- Lint-2026-05-05.md line 62–69 (the broken-slug list overlaps with this run's findings).
- synthetic-layer-2026-05-05.md line 67, 246 (seventh-run note about realist-thought slug).
- claims.md Counterpressure on
cryptic-institution-extends-beithandfaul-institutional-camp(Faul fabrication-incident audit-record positions).
- Confidence/status before → after: no claim or page status changes from this report.
- Report-only: no wiki edits.