Weave Survey: 2026-06-02

Run summary block (Pass 5 close)

Weave run (2026-06-02, DRY-RUN) — 5 passes complete. Mode: DRY-RUN (no relaxation entry in log.md; no same-session calibration PASS). No wiki content writes; all proposals staged in audit reports for maintainer hand-application / sign-off.

Cap Used / Limit Notes
Pass 2 stubs 0 / 3 0 new strong orphan HUBs (the 3 prior orphans were created; the Hegel/Heidegger HUB clusters are all homed). Backlog logged.
Pass 3 scans 4 / 15 2 explicitly-flagged pairs + 2 latent Gadamer↔MP pairs. 11 budget held.
Pass 3 candidates 0 / 6 3 Latent-Adjacent (bar candidate emission under v0d.9) + 1 Partial (emits none).
Pass 4 back-refs 10 / 10 the Hegel WdL cluster (8) + ereignis + haptocentrism — all HUB-motif homes that postdate the last Pass 4 (2026-05-16/17).

Pass 3 bridge cards: 3 staged Status: proposed (all latent-adjacent). False-friend cautions: 2 pages (the person↔flesh Partial — overturns the page's own prior prediction). Cross-pair engine-terminus check: done (3 termini of 1 Gadamer↔MP recurrence; 1 optional motifs.md BRIDGE entry deferred). Full Pass 3 detail: weave-pass3-2026-06-02.md + weave-pass3-2026-06-02-scans/.

Connection-graph survey (Pass 1) of the wiki's HUB-weight motif coverage. Read-only. Inputs Passes 2–4 of this run.

Inputs: wiki/motifs.md (HUB 56 / STRUCTURAL 50 / BRIDGE 11 / THEMES 15, per the 2026-06-01 Phase 3 motifs delta); wiki/claims.md (225 entries — 22 supported / 115 live / 86 candidate / 1 contested / 1 retired); wiki/concepts/ (445 pages); 68 concept pages carry ## Motif Weight & Corpus Recurrence back-reference sections.

Method note: this is a baseline-delta survey. The 2026-05-16 survey enumerated the then-36 HUB-tier motifs in a full table; that table remains the baseline for motifs 1–38 (largely unchanged). This survey computes the delta since 2026-05-16 — the Hegel Phenomenology (2026-05-18), Hegel WdL three-volume (2026-05-21), Heidegger GA 11 (2026-05-21), Madison (2026-05-22), Derrida cluster (2026-05-27), Nancy / Mounier (2026-05-28), Gadamer (2026-05-30) ingests + the 2026-06-01 Phase 3 motifs delta (Walten HUB + Schelling↔Simmel BRIDGE) all landed after the last full survey, adding ~20 HUB-tier motifs and ~170 concept pages (concepts 274 → 445).

Pass 1 narrative findings

Finding 1 — Orphan HUBs: 0 new strong candidates this run

  • The 2026-05-16 survey's 3 orphan-HUB candidates were all created (hand-applied after that dry-run): mythical-time.md, third-domain.md, enveloping-enveloped.md all exist. No action needed.
  • The large Hegel/Heidegger/Derrida HUB expansion since 2026-05-16 did not produce orphan HUBs: each new HUB motif has a dedicated home — the Hegel WdL cluster homes to -hegel-suffixed slugs (begriff-hegel, widerspruch-hegel, schein-hegel, reflexion-hegel, grund-hegel, plus aufheben, bestimmte-negation, allgemein-besonderes-einzelnes); schritt-zurueck, sache-selbst, recognition-and-institution, walten, ereignis, ge-stell, haptocentrism all exist.
  • the-uncanny (THEME, new 2026-06-01) is not a stub candidate: it was downgraded from STRUCTURAL to THEME in the 2026-06-01 Phase 3 delta (Heidegger-Protokoll mislocated, Morin "uncanny" imputed) with Derrida the only load-bearing author — THEME weight does not trigger the HUB-orphan rule. The [[the-uncanny]] stub link is an intentional forward-pointer.
  • Backlog logged for a future Pass 2 (potential orphans, not actioned this run; each needs a wiki-home confirmation + halt-for-review draft): the Derrida-cluster distributed motifs the hand / hand of man, hand of God (partial home at hand-of-god; no dedicated the-hand page), Nancy-cluster operators: exscription / syncope / partage (distributed), Christian body / chair / unerasable Christian semantics (home unconfirmed); and substance becomes subject (deliberately treated on the hegel-1807-phenomenology-spirit source page + g-w-f-hegel, no dedicated concept page — low priority, possibly intentional).

Finding 2 — Back-reference gap (the principal Pass 4 finding): the Hegel/Heidegger/Derrida HUB clusters lack ## Motif Weight & Corpus Recurrence sections

Only 68 / 445 concept pages carry the section. Every HUB motif that landed after the 2026-05-16/17 Pass 4 rollout lacks a back-reference, because no full weave Pass 4 has run since (the 2026-05-24 CR-014 run was a targeted Latent-Adjacent scan, not a survey). Confirmed HUB-motif home pages missing the section:

# Page Motif (motifs.md heading, verbatim) Weight Priority
1 aufheben Aufheben / sublation / cancel-preserve HUB (4 Hegel) HIGH
2 bestimmte-negation bestimmte Negation / determined negation HUB (4 Hegel) HIGH
3 widerspruch-hegel Widerspruch / productive contradiction HUB (4 Hegel) HIGH
4 begriff-hegel der Begriff / the Concept HUB (4 Hegel) HIGH
5 reflexion-hegel Reflexion (engine of the Doctrine of Essence) HUB (4 Hegel) HIGH
6 schein-hegel Schein / semblance / show HUB (3 Hegel) HIGH
7 grund-hegel Grund / ground / sufficient reason HUB (3 Hegel) HIGH
8 allgemein-besonderes-einzelnes Allgemein / Besonderes / Einzelnes (Universal / Particular / Individual) HUB (4 Hegel) HIGH
9 ereignis Ereignis HUB (Heidegger cluster) HIGH
10 haptocentrism haptocentric tradition / touch as metaphysics of presence HUB (Derrida) HIGH
— bildung Bildung / cultural formation HUB (Hegel + Gadamer) next run
— hand-of-god the hand / hand of man, hand of God HUB (Derrida) next run
— schritt-zurueck Schritt zurück / Sprung / Erwachen HUB (Heidegger) next run (verify)
— sache-selbst die Sache selbst / the matter itself HUB (Hegel + Husserl/Heidegger) next run (verify)

Pass 4 cap is 10/run. This run drafts sections for #1–#10 (the Hegel WdL cluster + ereignis + haptocentrism — a coherent batch from the WdL/GA11/Derrida ingests). The remainder is next-run backlog.

Important scope note: the 10 new Gadamer concept pages (hermeneutics, effective-history, fusion-of-horizons, prejudice, tradition, play-spiel, application-anwendung, hermeneutic-experience, linguisticality, aesthetic-consciousness) are single-source (Gadamer 1960) and therefore not Pass 4 candidates — the back-reference section points to a motifs.md HUB/STRUCTURAL entry, which a single-source concept does not yet have. They become Pass 4 candidates only once their concepts recur cross-source and are promoted to corpus-level motifs. (Several already accrue cross-source contact via this run's Pass 3 Latent-Adjacent cousinhoods — see Finding 4 — but that is a typed-connection relation, not a motif promotion.)

Finding 3 — Motif-to-claim gap (delta)

The new HUB clusters are, on the whole, well-claimed — the motif-to-claim gap did not widen materially:

  • Hegel WdL cluster: anchors live claims (freie-entlassung-as-non-transition, begriff-not-equatable-with-kantian-or-fregean, etc.); the productive-contradiction / Aufheben / bestimmte-Negation HUBs are claim-bearing.
  • Heidegger: walten-exceeds-onto-theological-sovereignty (live, promoted 2026-06-01).
  • Derrida: haptocentric-tradition-as-metaphysics-of-presence (live), heidegger-animal-doctrine-cross-decade-stable (live).
  • Gadamer: 3 candidates harvested at Phase 8 (2026-06-01) — post-husserlian-horizont-triangle (routed here, see Finding 4), gadamer-betti-dispute-genre-not-technique, gadamer-finite-erfahrung-pivots-hegel-to-phenomenology-finitude.

No NEW motif-derived claim candidates are emitted this run (Pass 3's verdicts are Latent-Adjacent/Partial, which do not authorize claims). Systematic motif-to-claim gap closure remains weave v2 Pass 8 territory.

Finding 4 — Pass 3 setup and results

Two pairs were explicitly routed to this Pass 3 (audit Phase 8 routed post-husserlian-horizont-triangle; the Mounier ingest flagged person↔flesh); two latent Gadamer↔MP pairs were added from the new ingest's grip-points. Results (full detail in weave-pass3-2026-06-02.md):

Pair Verdict Output
fusion-of-horizons ↔ horizons-of-language Latent-Adjacent confirms/de-hedges existing *has cross-tradition cousin* connections; post-husserlian-horizont-triangle stays candidate (cap retained)
effective-history ↔ institution Latent-Adjacent new *has cross-tradition cousin* (Wirkungsgeschichte axis; quarantined from the negative-artwork-Stiftung caution)
prejudice ↔ sedimentation Latent-Adjacent new *has cross-tradition cousin* (rehabilitated enabling-deposit)
personalism ↔ flesh-as-element Partial (false friend) revises the page's own prior pre-scan Latent-Adjacent prediction; false-friend caution + optional *contrasts with*

Meta-finding: the 3 Latent-Adjacent verdicts are three loci of one Gadamer↔MP cross-tradition recurrence (the post-Husserlian registral fork: language/tradition vs flesh/perception); the Partial marks its boundary. Candidate motifs.md BRIDGE recurrence entry drafted (deferred to maintainer).

Pass 2 — orphan-HUB stubs (cap 3; 0 used)

No stubs this run. Rationale in Finding 1: the 3 prior orphans were created; the new HUB clusters are homed; the-uncanny is a weak THEME. Backlog (Derrida-cluster distributed motifs + substance-becomes-subject) logged for a future Pass 2 with halt-for-review.

Pass 3 — structural-isomorphism scan (4 scans)

See weave-pass3-2026-06-02.md (lead-triage ledger, engine-terminus check, 3 bridge cards) and weave-pass3-2026-06-02-scans/scan-{1..4}-*.md (per-pair triples, axis comparisons, veto + five-condition checks). Validator scripts/validate_weave_pass3.py: PASS.

Pass 4 — back-reference section drafts (cap 10; 10 drafted, dry-run)

Template per CLAUDE.md ## Motif Weight & Corpus Recurrence. Page-level rules: insert after ## Connections, before ## Open Questions; bump updated: (substantive cross-reference addition per GR3 exception). Motif heading referenced inline (§"..."), not via [[motifs#anchor]] (headings contain slashes/accents). Not written in dry-run — drafted here for hand-application.

Pass 4 draft 1 of 10 — aufheben

## Motif Weight & Corpus Recurrence

This concept is tracked at corpus level in [[motifs]] under §"Aufheben / sublation / cancel-preserve" as a **HUB** motif, attested across 4 Hegel sources plus substantial cross-tradition reception (see `motifs.md` for the current attestation list, source-level weights, and the *tollere*/*supprimer* cancel-vs-preserve genealogy + the Marxist-vs-Adornian reception fork). Update both this section and the `motifs.md` entry when corpus weight shifts.

Pass 4 draft 2 of 10 — bestimmte-negation

## Motif Weight & Corpus Recurrence

This concept is tracked at corpus level in [[motifs]] under §"bestimmte Negation / determined negation" as a **HUB** motif, attested across 4 Hegel sources (see `motifs.md` for the current attestation list, source-level weights, and the labor-of-the-negative identity resolution + the Adorno / MP-redoubled-negation cross-tradition fork). Update both this section and the `motifs.md` entry when corpus weight shifts.

Pass 4 draft 3 of 10 — widerspruch-hegel

## Motif Weight & Corpus Recurrence

This concept is tracked at corpus level in [[motifs]] under §"Widerspruch / productive contradiction" as a **HUB** motif, attested across 4 Hegel sources plus Adorno/Lukács cross-tradition reception (see `motifs.md` for the current attestation list, source-level weights, and the Aristotle-PNC-reversal → Marx → Adorno genealogy). Update both this section and the `motifs.md` entry when corpus weight shifts.

Pass 4 draft 4 of 10 — begriff-hegel

## Motif Weight & Corpus Recurrence

This concept is tracked at corpus level in [[motifs]] under §"der Begriff / the Concept" as a **HUB** motif, attested across 4 Hegel sources plus Kantian cross-tradition (see `motifs.md` for the current attestation list, source-level weights, and the Kant-apperception / Frege-Begriff non-equation per [[claims#begriff-not-equatable-with-kantian-or-fregean]]). Update both this section and the `motifs.md` entry when corpus weight shifts.

Pass 4 draft 5 of 10 — reflexion-hegel

## Motif Weight & Corpus Recurrence

This concept is tracked at corpus level in [[motifs]] under §"Reflexion (engine of the Doctrine of Essence)" as a **HUB** motif, attested across 4 Hegel sources plus post-Kantian cross-tradition (see `motifs.md` for the current attestation list, source-level weights, and the *absoluter Gegenstoß* structure + the MP *philosophie-de-la-réflexion* false-friend caution — Hegel's Wesen-Reflexion is **not** MP's polemical target). Update both this section and the `motifs.md` entry when corpus weight shifts.

Pass 4 draft 6 of 10 — schein-hegel

## Motif Weight & Corpus Recurrence

This concept is tracked at corpus level in [[motifs]] under §"Schein / semblance / show" as a **HUB** motif, attested across 3 Hegel sources plus cross-tradition (see `motifs.md` for the current attestation list, source-level weights, and the Schein/Erscheinung distinction + the Kant-Erscheinung-as-Schein-misrecognized polemic + the MP *apparaître* cousin). Update both this section and the `motifs.md` entry when corpus weight shifts.

Pass 4 draft 7 of 10 — grund-hegel

## Motif Weight & Corpus Recurrence

This concept is tracked at corpus level in [[motifs]] under §"Grund / ground / sufficient reason" as a **HUB** motif, attested across 3 Hegel sources plus Leibniz–Heidegger cross-tradition (see `motifs.md` for the current attestation list, source-level weights, and the Leibniz-PSR → Hegel-self-aufhebende-Grund → Heidegger-*Satz-vom-Grund* genealogy). Update both this section and the `motifs.md` entry when corpus weight shifts.

Pass 4 draft 8 of 10 — allgemein-besonderes-einzelnes

## Motif Weight & Corpus Recurrence

This concept is tracked at corpus level in [[motifs]] under §"Allgemein / Besonderes / Einzelnes (Universal / Particular / Individual)" as a **HUB** motif, attested across 4 Hegel sources plus Aristotelian cross-tradition (see `motifs.md` for the current attestation list, source-level weights, and the AABE-rhythm structuring the judgment-types / syllogism-types / objectivity / Idea triads). Update both this section and the `motifs.md` entry when corpus weight shifts.

Pass 4 draft 9 of 10 — ereignis

## Motif Weight & Corpus Recurrence

This concept is tracked at corpus level in [[motifs]] under §"Ereignis" as a **HUB** motif, attested across the Heidegger GA 11 + prior-Heidegger-cluster aggregation (see `motifs.md` for the current attestation list and source-level weights, incl. the *Walten des Austrags = Ereignis* identification at GA 11 Randbemerkung 93, and the *Ge-stell* → *Ereignis* relation). Update both this section and the `motifs.md` entry when corpus weight shifts.

Pass 4 draft 10 of 10 — haptocentrism

## Motif Weight & Corpus Recurrence

This concept is tracked at corpus level in [[motifs]] under §"haptocentric tradition / touch as metaphysics of presence" as a **HUB** motif, attested across the Derrida *On Touching* + *Beast & Sovereign* corpus (see `motifs.md` for the current attestation list and source-level weights, incl. the Spanish-mystics-as-limit-case finding and the link to [[claims#haptocentric-tradition-as-metaphysics-of-presence]] live). Update both this section and the `motifs.md` entry when corpus weight shifts.

Pass 4 cap reached (10/10). Backlog: bildung, hand-of-god, schritt-zurueck, sache-selbst (verify back-ref absence first).

Recommendation / next steps

  1. Bridge-card sign-off is the natural next step for the 3 Latent-Adjacent cards in weave-pass3-2026-06-02.md (Card 1 = confirm/de-hedge existing connections; Cards 2–3 = new connections). All three fall within the v0d.9 Latent-Adjacent apply-mode carve-out (typed connections + Open-Questions cautions + optional motifs.md BRIDGE entry AUTHORIZED; claims.md candidate NOT authorized).
  2. The person↔flesh false-friend correction (Pair 4) is independently applicable — it revises a now-falsified prediction already on personalism.md; worth applying regardless of the bridge-card track.
  3. Pass 4 back-reference rollout (10 drafts) is low-risk and mechanical; hand-apply or schedule an apply-mode run.
  4. The motifs.md BRIDGE recurrence entry (Gadamer↔MP registral fork) is a maintainer corpus-weight judgment; staged, not applied.
  5. To enable apply mode for a future run, a same-session Pass 3 calibration PASS (maintainer-adjudicated) is required; the dry-run default has not been relaxed.