Synthetic-Layer Assembly — Fifteenth Run (2026-05-21)

Context: Post-GA-11-ingest audit. Processes 3 GA 11 extraction-note claim candidates deferred from today's ingest, plus 1 fourteenth-run deferral unblocked by GA 11 ingest (braig-quelle-of-onto-theo-logik). Also triages 2 SuZ-derived deferrals and 1 ZuS deferral.

Procedure: 3-test gate for candidate → live; 5-test gate for live → supported. Per CLAUDE.md durable rule, supported promotions HALT for human review.

Candidate Pool (7)

# Candidate Source Prior status Decision
1 ga11-sprung-to-erwachen-reframes-late-method GA 11 extraction NEW PROMOTE → live
2 ga11-austrag-as-wesensherkunft-of-onto-theo-logik GA 11 extraction NEW PROMOTE → live
3 ga11-kehre-as-sachverhalt-not-biography GA 11 extraction NEW PROMOTE → live
4 braig-quelle-of-onto-theo-logik Mein Weg + GA 11 UNBLOCKED PROMOTE → live
5 sein-und-zeit-as-mp-silent-interlocutor SuZ extraction Integration check MERGE into Step 8.5 page upgrade
6 destruktion-as-the-method-mp-inherits-and-transforms SuZ extraction SA-2006 check needed HOLD — SA-2006 evidence chain thin
7 Überwindung → Ablassen → Preisgabe trajectory ZuS extraction STILL BLOCKED HOLD — source not in raw

3-Test Gate Application

1. ga11-sprung-to-erwachen-reframes-late-method → live (medium)

  • T1: Contestable — one can argue Beilagen are exploratory marginalia not definitive corrections; the Beiträge (GA 65) Sprung-figure is unretracted; Erwachen may supplement rather than replace.
  • T2: Anchored — Anhang p. 83 + Beilagen I (Umschlag + Blätter 1–9) + Beilagen II (Blätter 1–6), all documented in extraction note.
  • T3: Three counterpressure bullets recorded: editorial-genetic caution; Beiträge Sprung unretracted; supplement-vs-replacement reading.

2. ga11-austrag-as-wesensherkunft-of-onto-theo-logik → live (medium)

  • T1: Contestable — the Austrag could be description rather than origin; the vocabulary is local to GA 11.
  • T2: Anchored — pp. 83–89 + Randbemerkung (93) "das Walten des Austrags: Ereignis."
  • T3: Three counterpressure bullets: description-vs-origin; local-vocabulary concern; marginalia evidential weight.

3. ga11-kehre-as-sachverhalt-not-biography → live (high)

  • T1: Strongly contestable — the dominant secondary-literature biographical reading is the default.
  • T2: Anchored — Richardson letter p. 152 + Die Kehre pp. 118–120 + GA 45 p. 214. Three convergent texts spanning 1937/38–1962.
  • T3: Scholarly-momentum counterpressure + 1949/1962 temporal gap + what-vs-how distinction.

4. braig-quelle-of-onto-theo-logik → live (medium)

  • T1: Contestable — retrospective-construction objection; biographical vs philosophical genealogy.
  • T2: Anchored — GA 14 pp. 92–93 (verbatim Braig passages from Mein Weg) + GA 11 pp. 51–80 (systematic text). Two-source cross-corroboration.
  • T3: Three counterpressure bullets: retrospective-construction; biographical-vs-philosophical; single-source-retroactive.
  • Unblock note: Originally deferred in fourteenth run pending Identität und Differenz ingest. GA 11 ingested today; the systematic text is now available.

5. sein-und-zeit-as-mp-silent-interlocutor → MERGE

The SuZ-specific claim (MP rewrites S&Z's In-der-Welt-sein as corporeal être-au-monde) overlaps substantially with the existing heidegger-as-silenced-interlocutor page, which was confirmed "already complete" in the fourteenth-run follow-up. The SuZ-specific insight (Befindlichkeit→corporeal schema; Sorge→intentional arc; Zeitlichkeit→pre-objective temporality) is better deployed as a Step 8.5 subsection upgrade to that page than as a standalone claim entry. Deferred to next Step 8.5 sweep.

6. destruktion-as-the-method-mp-inherits-and-transforms → HOLD

The SuZ §6 Destruktion-statement is clear, but the MP-side / SA-2006 cross-reading has not been established in the extraction notes. The SA-2006 extraction note does not contain explicit destruktion/archaeological method content. The claim stays deferred pending a targeted raw-source check of SA-2006's indirect-method chapter.

7. Überwindung → Ablassen → Preisgabe trajectory → HOLD

Still blocked: Überwindung der Metaphysik (1954) not in raw. No action.

Dead Claim References Fixed

3 dead [[claims#...]] references on motifs.md (from today's GA 11 ingest follow-up) resolved by the 4 new claim entries:

  • [[claims#ga11-sprung-to-erwachen-reframes-late-method]] (line 208) — updated "candidate, deferred" → "live claim, 2026-05-21"
  • [[claims#ga11-austrag-as-wesensherkunft-of-onto-theo-logik]] (line 422) — updated
  • [[claims#braig-quelle-of-onto-theo-logik]] (line 429) — updated

Final Tally

  • 4 new entries created at live
  • 0 supported promotions (none candidates this run)
  • 1 merge decision (sein-und-zeit-as-mp-silent-interlocutor → Step 8.5 page upgrade)
  • 2 holds (destruktion + Überwindung trajectory)
  • 3 motifs.md dead-ref fixes

Register state after this run: 177 → 181 claim entries (19 supported / 103 live / 58 candidate / 1 contested / 0 retired)

Deferred to next run