title: "Major-Volume Integration & Targeted Raw-Check Report — Full Audit v1.5, 2026-05-05" type: audit-report date: 2026-05-05 phase: 4 + 5

Major-Volume Integration & Targeted Raw-Check — 2026-05-05

Run summary

  • Audit: Full Audit v1.5, 2026-05-05
  • Owner: Agent D (report-only; no edits to wiki pages)
  • Scope: Phase 4 (major-volume integration triage on post-2026-04-28 ingests) + Phase 5 (targeted raw-source checks for Rule 18 and hard-absence framings)
  • Inputs: wiki/.audit/raw-inventory-2026-05-05.md; wiki/.audit/saint-aubert-backlog.md; wiki/.audit/synthetic-layer-2026-05-05.md (cite-back queue at lines 165–198); wiki/sources/merleau-ponty-1942-structure-of-behavior.md; wiki/sources/merleau-ponty-2010-child-psychology-pedagogy.md; wiki/sources/morris-2024-wild-structure-melting-time.md; wiki/sources/decarie-daigneault-2024-crooked-finger.md; wiki/sources/merleau-ponty-1947-humanism-and-terror.md; wiki/claims.md (full register, with focus on supported claims and seventh-run additions); a sample of concept and entity pages flagged in the cite-back deferred queue and Saint Aubert backlog.
  • Headline finding: Phase 8 seventh run produced 12 live + 1 supported + 6 candidate register actions but discharged only 13 of the cite-back targets at that run; the seventh-run report explicitly defers 13+ further pages, all of which remain undischarged. The Tier 1 source pages themselves are well-written; the integration debt sits outward — on concept pages whose bodies have not yet absorbed what the new ingests reformulate or correct, and on Wiki-home concept pages that should but do not yet cite the new claims.
  • Phase 5 verdict: the three targeted Rule 18 checks performed all confirm the existing readings; no anchor needs reframing. Hard absences are durable and gate ~6 candidate→live or live→supported promotions.

Phase 4 — Major-volume integration triage

Tier 1 ingests

SB 1942 — merleau-ponty-1942-structure-of-behavior (ingested 2026-05-05)

The source page is dense and high-quality (created 2026-05-05; high confidence; 280+ lines). The seventh-run cite-backs already discharged for SB 1942: kinetic-melody-of-behavior ((live) framing removed for the supported promotion). Three live/supported/candidate claims have SB 1942 as wiki home or evidence anchor: mp-1942-already-prefigures-late-sedimentation (live), sb-1942-kinetic-melody-origin (supported), sb-ch3-contains-wild-structure-germ (candidate).

Pages where SB 1942 is now in the source's sources: frontmatter but the body has not absorbed SB-specific content: [[perceptual-faith]] (cites SB 1942 in its frontmatter; the body does not yet engage SB Ch IV's "realism as well-founded error" as the structural ancestor of perceptual faith — claim type: corrective absence). [[three-orders-of-signification]] (same — SB 1942 is in sources: but the body is not yet anchored to Ch III's "matter / life / mind as three orders of significations" raw 1356 with the SB-specific framing).

Pages where SB 1942 should be in sources: but is not, and the body uses concepts SB 1942 reformulates:

  • [[passivity]] — wiki home for mp-1942-already-prefigures-late-sedimentation (live). The page's sources: does not include merleau-ponty-1942-structure-of-behavior; the body does not register SB Ch IV note 50 raw 2653 as the 1942 attestation of original/secondary passivity. High-priority cite-back gap.
  • [[sedimentation]] — wiki home for mp-1942-already-prefigures-late-sedimentation (live). Same gap — the page lists ten sources but not SB 1942. High-priority cite-back gap.
  • [[stiftung]] — wiki home for mp-1942-already-prefigures-late-sedimentation (live). Same gap. High-priority cite-back gap.
  • [[interanimality]] — explicitly named in sb-1942-kinetic-melody-origin (supported)'s "wiki homes" field; the seventh-run report flags it as deferred pending Synthetic Claims supported-citation update. SB 1942 not yet integrated.
  • [[motor-intentionality]] — same: wiki home for sb-1942-kinetic-melody-origin (supported); cite-back deferred.
  • [[fundamental-thought-in-art]] — same; cite-back deferred.
  • [[institution]] — wiki home for sb-1942-kinetic-melody-origin (supported). Per seventh-run report line 175, institution received 3 cite-back additions this run (spontaneous-structuration, no-causality, culture-as-milieu) but the SB 1942 supported citation update was not yet logged.
  • [[wild-structure]] — wiki home for sb-ch3-contains-wild-structure-germ (candidate). Already cites SB 1942 (and contains a "deformation of SB-structure" connection); but does not yet cite the candidate claim in a Synthetic Claims section.
  • [[freud-without-demonology]] — does not yet cite SB 1942 even though SB Ch III raw 1670–1698 is "the proximate origin of MP's later 'generative psychoanalysis'" per the SB source page Concepts Developed entry. Substantive interpretive gap.
  • [[schneider-case]] — does not yet cite SB 1942 even though SB Ch II raw 822–834 is MP's original treatment of the Schneider case, predating PoP by 3 years. Substantive interpretive gap.

Pages whose body uses concepts SB reformulates without acknowledging the reformulation:

  • [[perceptual-faith]] — the body does not register SB Ch IV "realism as well-founded error" (raw 1984) as the structural ancestor.
  • [[behavior-as-form]] — page exists; check needed for whether SB Ch I §Conclusion raw 682 definition is the body's anchor (not checked exhaustively in this run).
  • [[propaedeutic-dialectic]] — SB's argumentative-form characterization names propaedeutic-dialectic as the form of SB itself; whether the wiki page registers SB as a primary attestation site is uncertain.

CPP — merleau-ponty-2010-child-psychology-pedagogy (ingested 2026-05-04)

Highly dense source page (336 lines; 21 numbered Core Arguments; 14 concepts developed). Seventh-run cite-backs already discharged: culturalism-mp (4 claims), realist-thought, broad-vs-narrow-psychoanalysis (2 claims), ambiguity-vs-ambivalence (1 claim), spontaneous-structuration (1 claim), institution (3 claims).

Pages where CPP is in sources: but the body lacks the concept-page-specific extension:

  • [[body-schema]] — CPP is in sources: but the body has not yet absorbed CPP's developmental anchoring (pre-3 months no total body schema; 3-6 months myelination; the "starting condition that is differentiated, not constructed" formulation). High-yield interpretive gap.
  • [[adultomorphism]], [[infantile-polymorphism]], [[lived-gestural-expression]], [[convergence-thesis-mp]], [[third-year-crisis]], [[ultra-things]], [[specular-image]] — most cite CPP as a source already; depth of body-text integration varies.

Pages where CPP should be in sources: but is not, and the body uses concepts CPP reformulates:

  • [[transitivism]] — wiki home for the developmental Wallon-derived material; sources: lists only merleau-ponty-1964-primacy-of-perception (the partial Cobb/Wild translation). CPP source page extraction note explicitly flags that Cobb/Wild are pre-1964 and omit substantial material that Welsh/Verdier preserves; transitivism page should add CPP and add the chapter 5 §V transitivism is surpassed in the order of habitual life, but not in the order of feelings formulation. High-priority philological gap (cross-translation).
  • [[syncretic-sociability]] — same: sources: includes Primacy of Perception but not CPP. The CPP extraction note records ch. 5 §II as the developmental-anchor passage; the page should add CPP and Welsh-edition material.
  • [[gender-as-cultural-developmental]] — concept page exists per CPP Concepts Developed list; check needed whether it is anchored on CPP ch. 7 §IX line 5218 (the Stendhal-Mead methodological homology). Wiki home for mp-beauvoir-1949-convergence-on-gender (candidate).
  • [[wesensschau-as-observation]] — CPP-developed concept page; CPP ch. 6 §II.A line 4280 anchor. Cross-source check pending.

Cite-back deferred from seventh run:

  • [[convergence-thesis-mp]] — wiki home for convergence-thesis-prefigures-lateral-universality (candidate). Page contains a stale slug reference (convergence-thesis-prefigures-lateral-universality-and-philosophy-of-biology) that does not match the canonical claim slug convergence-thesis-prefigures-lateral-universality. Lint-level slug-correction gap.
  • [[lateral-universal]] — wiki home for the same candidate; cite-back deferred per seventh-run line 196.
  • [[simone-de-beauvoir]] — wiki home for mp-beauvoir-1949-convergence-on-gender (candidate). Per seventh-run line 197: "simone-de-beauvoir (currently a stub-level entity) — mp-beauvoir candidate citation pending." CONFIRMED: the entity page does not exist (no file wiki/entities/simone-de-beauvoir.md). The wiki has a [[simone-de-beauvoir]] wikilink target with no resolving file.

Morris 2024 — morris-2024-wild-structure-melting-time (ingested 2026-05-05)

Source page solid (high confidence; 5 concept pages spawned). Phase 8 seventh-run cite-backs to wild-being (3 claims), melting-time (3 claims) discharged. The companion concept pages melting-time, wild-structure, ontogenesis-of-time, processioning, imperfecting-expression are all freshly created and in good shape.

Pages where Morris is now in sources: but the body has not absorbed Morris-specific content:

  • [[indirect-ontology]] — Morris is now in the source list (page line 205) and appears under the QBism convergence reading; the page does NOT yet cite claims#wild-being-extends-to-physics (live) in its Synthetic Claims section. Cite-back deferred per seventh-run line 190.
  • [[wild-structure]] — already cites Morris but its Synthetic Claims section does not yet include the seventh-run candidate claim citations explicitly. Per seventh-run line 192: candidate citations quantum-systems-exhibit-merleau-pontian-wild-structure and sb-ch3-contains-wild-structure-germ are pending. Also: the page line 91 has a slug-mis-pointing flagged for next lint (cites SB pages "148/137, 153/142, 155/143" under wrong source slug merleau-ponty-1945-phenomenology-of-perception; should be merleau-ponty-1942-structure-of-behavior). Lint-level slug-mis-point and cite-back gap.
  • [[volant]] — Morris's ur-volant extension is registered in the source page Concepts Developed but not yet in the Volant page body. Single-attestation, so currently fine to defer.
  • [[ecart]] — Morris's "écart of time from change" is a new register; whether the existing ecart page registers this as a Connection is not checked.

Pages where Morris should be in sources: but is not:

  • [[chiasm]] — wiki home for h-and-t-political-articulation-of-mps-open-ontology (live, also from this run); the chiasm page does not yet cite Morris (which would not be required for the H&T claim, but Morris's transposition of MP-political to MP-physics is itself a cross-register move chiasm should register). Defer to next ingest cycle interpretive work.

DD 2024 — decarie-daigneault-2024-crooked-finger (ingested 2026-05-05)

Source page solid (high confidence). Concept pages passence, transtemporality, double-sided-artifact, encounter-deleuze, depth-of-time freshly created and well-anchored.

Pages where DD 2024 is now wiki home but the page lacks a Synthetic Claims section:

  • [[transtemporality]] — wiki home for transtemporality-as-double-sided-encounter-structure (candidate) and cave-paintings-as-liminal-encounter (candidate). Page has no Synthetic Claims section. Cite-back deferred per seventh-run line 193.
  • [[passence]] — wiki home for cave-paintings-as-liminal-encounter (candidate) and passence-as-mp-presence-of-absence (candidate). Page has no Synthetic Claims section. Cite-back deferred per seventh-run line 194.
  • [[double-sided-artifact]] — wiki home for cave-paintings-as-liminal-encounter (candidate) and transtemporality-as-double-sided-encounter-structure (candidate). Page has no Synthetic Claims section. Cite-back deferred per seventh-run line 194.
  • [[encounter-deleuze]] — wiki home for transtemporality-as-double-sided-encounter-structure (candidate). Page has no Synthetic Claims section. Cite-back deferred per seventh-run line 195.

Pages whose bergson-mp-deleuze-naissance-continue (live) is now extended by DD 2024: the claim's Sources field was updated at the 2026-05-05 ingest with DD 2024 as second articulation; this is already discharged.

H&T 1947 — merleau-ponty-1947-humanism-and-terror (ingested 2026-05-04)

Source page extensively rebuilt at 2026-05-05 with H&T-derived Synthetic Claims (5 entries: 4 live + 1 candidate). Seventh-run cite-backs discharged: contingency-of-the-future, humanism-in-extension, merleau-ponty-1947-humanism-and-terror source page itself.

Cite-back deferred from seventh run:

  • [[nikolai-bukharin]] — wiki home for bukharin-as-mp-exemplar-phenomenological-political-ethics (live). Page already lists H&T as primary source; what is pending is the Synthetic Claims section. Currently absent. Cite-back deferred per seventh-run line 187.
  • [[historical-responsibility]] — wiki home for bukharin-as-mp-exemplar-phenomenological-political-ethics (live). Page lacks a Synthetic Claims section despite being a major H&T-derived problem-space concept. Cite-back deferred per seventh-run line 187.
  • [[merleau-ponty-1955-adventures-of-the-dialectic]] — wiki home for mp-1947-1955-break-evidential-weight-of-contingency (live) and h-and-t-anticipates-sartre-mp-rupture (candidate). Source page lacks Synthetic Claims section. Cite-back deferred per seventh-run line 188.
  • [[chiasm]] — wiki home for h-and-t-political-articulation-of-mps-open-ontology (live). The chiasm page Synthetic Claims section does not yet cite this live claim. Cite-back deferred per seventh-run line 189.
  • [[wild-being]] — wiki home for h-and-t-political-articulation-of-mps-open-ontology (live). The wild-being page does not yet cite this claim in its Synthetic Claims section (which currently has three Morris-derived entries). Pending.
  • [[jean-paul-sartre]] — wiki home for h-and-t-anticipates-sartre-mp-rupture (candidate). Cite-back deferred per seventh-run line 198.

Tier 2 ingests (light-touch summary)

  • Saint Aubert 2023 (saintaubert-2023-etre-et-chair): integrated through the 2026-04-25 audit Phase 4 (11 pages reviewed). The Saint Aubert backlog at saint-aubert-backlog.md records 5 Priority A and 10 Priority B pages still deferred. All four Priority A pages I checked (hyper-reflection, lebenswelt, ontological-difference, nonphilosophy) currently contain no Saint Aubert citations — the 2026-04-25 deferred list is intact. These remain blocked principally by Saint Aubert 2006 (Vers une ontologie indirecte) hard-absence on most thematically central pages.
  • Heidegger Nietzsche I, II, Das Ende: integrated through the 2026-05-04 fifth Phase 8 run; cite-backs visible at friedrich-nietzsche, will-to-power, eternal-recurrence, seinsgeschichte, vollendung-der-metaphysik, circulus-vitiosus-deus (the supported claim).
  • Texts and Dialogues (merleau-ponty-1992-texts-and-dialogues): integrated; Chapsal-1960 anchor visible at wild-being and ontology-of-the-object. Wiki home for chapsal-1960-public-anchor-for-ontology-of-object-rejection (candidate).
  • Chouraqui 2025 — Healing Schneider: integrated; cite-backs visible at healing-schneider, schneider-case, freud-without-demonology, agnosia-mp.
  • Inédits I, II: integrated through the 2026-05-04 fifth Phase 8 run + this run's inedits-i-as-humanism-and-terror-laboratory candidate→live promotion. Wiki home pages updated.
  • Inkpin 2026: substantially integrated per prior runs (per Briefing line 99 — light-touch). concrete-mediation is the principal anchor; the false-friend caution in CPP carries forward.

Triage groupings

Apply during this audit (Lead applies — mechanically clear from extraction notes)

These are the items where the SB 1942, CPP, or H&T extraction note authorizes a specific section addition or text revision and the source page is already in good shape:

  1. [[passivity]] — add SB 1942 to sources: and add a brief Synthetic Claims section citing mp-1942-already-prefigures-late-sedimentation (live). SB Ch IV note 50 raw 2653 verifies the natural-body / cultural-body / sedimentation framework; the seventh-run report lists passivity as a wiki home for this live claim but did not log the cite-back. Mechanically clear from the SB 1942 source-page Connections section and from the live claim's Wiki homes field.
  2. [[sedimentation]] — add SB 1942 to sources: and add Synthetic Claims section citing mp-1942-already-prefigures-late-sedimentation (live). Same authorization.
  3. [[stiftung]] — add SB 1942 to sources: and add Synthetic Claims entry citing mp-1942-already-prefigures-late-sedimentation (live). Same authorization. (The page already has a Synthetic Claims section; the entry is additive.)
  4. [[transitivism]] — add [[merleau-ponty-2010-child-psychology-pedagogy]] to sources: and add a paragraph or subsection on the chapter 5 §V "transitivism is surpassed in the order of habitual life, but not in the order of feelings" formulation. The CPP extraction note explicitly flags Cobb/Wild as omitting material; the page currently relies on Cobb/Wild only.
  5. [[syncretic-sociability]] — add CPP to sources: and add chapter 5 §II material; same Welsh/Verdier philological correction.
  6. [[interanimality]] / [[motor-intentionality]] / [[fundamental-thought-in-art]] — update existing references to (live) framing of sb-1942-kinetic-melody-origin to (supported) framing. The seventh-run report (line 191) explicitly queues this. Mechanical update.
  7. [[wild-structure]] line 91 — fix slug-mis-point: cites SB pages "148/137, 153/142, 155/143" under wrong source slug merleau-ponty-1945-phenomenology-of-perception; should be merleau-ponty-1942-structure-of-behavior. Lint-level mechanical fix; explicitly deferred at SB 1942 ingest per user direction; ripe now.
  8. [[convergence-thesis-mp]] — replace stale slug convergence-thesis-prefigures-lateral-universality-and-philosophy-of-biology with canonical convergence-thesis-prefigures-lateral-universality (lines 14 and 66 of that page). Mechanical fix (companion to the seventh-run lint findings on stale slugs at lines 246–247 of synthetic-layer report).

Cite-back / Synthetic Claims section work (Agent E will pick up in Phase 8 eighth run)

These are the seventh-run report's explicit "cite-back deferred to next run" queue (lines 185–198), confirmed by direct inspection:

  1. [[nikolai-bukharin]] and [[historical-responsibility]] — add Synthetic Claims section + cite bukharin-as-mp-exemplar-phenomenological-political-ethics (live).
  2. [[merleau-ponty-1955-adventures-of-the-dialectic]] source page — add Synthetic Claims section + cite mp-1947-1955-break-evidential-weight-of-contingency (live) and h-and-t-anticipates-sartre-mp-rupture (candidate).
  3. [[chiasm]] Synthetic Claims section — add h-and-t-political-articulation-of-mps-open-ontology (live) entry. (Page has Synthetic Claims; this is additive.)
  4. [[wild-being]] Synthetic Claims section — add h-and-t-political-articulation-of-mps-open-ontology (live) entry. (Page has Synthetic Claims with three Morris-derived entries; this is additive.)
  5. [[indirect-ontology]] Synthetic Claims section — add wild-being-extends-to-physics (live) entry. (Page has Synthetic Claims with six entries; this is additive.)
  6. [[wild-structure]] Synthetic Claims section — add quantum-systems-exhibit-merleau-pontian-wild-structure (candidate) and sb-ch3-contains-wild-structure-germ (candidate) entries.
  7. [[transtemporality]], [[passence]], [[double-sided-artifact]], [[encounter-deleuze]] — create Synthetic Claims sections citing the seventh-run candidates (transtemporality-as-double-sided-encounter-structure, cave-paintings-as-liminal-encounter, passence-as-mp-presence-of-absence per page). All four pages currently lack Synthetic Claims sections.
  8. [[convergence-thesis-mp]] and [[lateral-universal]] — cite convergence-thesis-prefigures-lateral-universality (candidate) (after slug-correction in #8).
  9. [[simone-de-beauvoir]] — create the entity stub page (currently a dangling wikilink target). Cite mp-beauvoir-1949-convergence-on-gender (candidate).
  10. [[jean-paul-sartre]] — cite h-and-t-anticipates-sartre-mp-rupture (candidate) in a Synthetic Claims section.
  11. [[institution]] Synthetic Claims update — change (live) framing of sb-1942-kinetic-melody-origin to (supported). (The page received 3 cite-backs this run but the SB-supported framing update was not yet logged.)

Defer to next ingest cycle (interpretive work)

  1. [[perceptual-faith]] body integration of SB Ch IV "realism as well-founded error" as the structural ancestor — interpretive synthesis beyond the mechanical Sources update.
  2. [[freud-without-demonology]] body integration of SB Ch III's Freud-as-structure-not-cause material as proximate origin of MP's later "generative psychoanalysis" — interpretive synthesis.
  3. [[schneider-case]] body integration of SB Ch II raw 822–834 as MP's original treatment — interpretive synthesis on the philological priority claim.
  4. [[body-schema]] integration of CPP's developmental anchoring (pre-3 months / 3-6 months myelination / "starting condition that is differentiated, not constructed") — interpretive synthesis.
  5. [[behavior-as-form]] body integration: SB Ch I §Conclusion raw 682 definition, three-form taxonomy, transverse functions — interpretive synthesis.
  6. [[gender-as-cultural-developmental]] body integration of CPP ch. 7 §IX line 5218 Stendhal-Mead methodological homology + Beauvoir cite — gated by Beauvoir hard absence (see below).
  7. Saint Aubert backlog Priority A pages ([[hyper-reflection]], [[lebenswelt]], [[ontological-difference]], [[nonphilosophy]], [[schneider-case]]) — all five from the 2026-04-25 backlog still untouched. Substantial interpretive work; the backlog file remains accurate.
  8. Saint Aubert backlog Priority B pages (10 pages: [[visible-invisible]], [[motor-intentionality]], [[body-schema]], [[hyper-objet]]-related upstreams, [[generative-passivity]], [[interanimality]], [[intra-ontology]], [[dehiscence]], [[phenomenal-field]], [[primordial-symbolism]]) — all from 2026-04-25 backlog still untouched.

Genuine gaps without raw access (hard-absence gates)

  1. Saint Aubert 2006 (Vers une ontologie indirecte, Vrin) — gates Saint Aubert backlog Priority A pages, science-secrete-stiftung-chiasm (live → would-be supported), wild-being-extends-to-physics (live; physics extension might be qualified by 2006 framework), time-as-late-mp-privileged-ontological-clue (candidate).
  2. Beauvoir, Le deuxième sexe (1949) — gates mp-beauvoir-1949-convergence-on-gender (candidate) and [[gender-as-cultural-developmental]] body integration. CPP ch. 7 §IX line 5218 cites Beauvoir explicitly; without Beauvoir-side ingest the claim cannot be moved to live.
  3. Berghofer-Wiltsche 2024 (Phenomenology and QBism) — Morris note 4 acknowledges this volume. Gates wild-structure Open Question on cross-source attestation and could promote wild-being-extends-to-physics (live) toward supported.
  4. Reynolds 2002 / 2004 — gates parergon-cezanne-mp-outlines-structural-parallel (candidate, low) → live.
  5. Saint Aubert 2013 (Du corps au désir) — gates desire/body/vrai dehors page integration.

Phase 5 — Targeted raw checks

Rule 18 retrospective verifications

The audit identified six supported claims as of 2026-05-05. Of these, the three with evidence anchors created on or before 2026-04-25 (i.e., extraction notes ≥10 days old as measured from this audit; per Rule 18 / artifact conservatism, these are candidates for re-anchoring under newer corpus context):

Claim Evidence-anchor age Rule 18 verdict Notes
valery-mauvaises-pensees-attribution 2026-04-27 (Valéry tome II ingest); reaffirmed 2026-04-29 + 2026-05-04 Anchor still holds The verbatim French at raw 23403 ("L'artiste apporte son corps... organe qui s'accommode, se déforme...") is the unambiguous textual anchor. Newer ingests (Heidegger, Inédits, H&T, SB 1942, CPP, Morris, DD) do not alter the local-context reading. The chronological-priority sub-thesis was discharged by Malraux 1953 ingest at 2026-04-29; that discharge is durable.
coherent-deformation-universal-operative-form 2026-04-28 (PoP / IL re-audit) Anchor still holds The cardinal IL raw 1050 passage ("The meaning of a novel too is perceptible at first only as a coherent deformation... And it will never be otherwise") and PoP §IIb raw 597 anchor are durable. The Indirect Language (1952) privileging of language over painting is a published-text feature that newer ingests do not alter. SB 1942 ingest does NOT introduce the term déformation cohérente (verified at the SB source page Terminology row: "déformation cohérente (NOT in SB; the term enters MP via Malraux 1953)"). The supported claim remains stable.
circulus-vitiosus-deus-mp-ontology-of-ontology 2026-04-29 (created); promoted to supported 2026-05-04 after Heidegger Nietzsche I/II ingests Anchor still holds The V&I 179/231 working note is the unique textual anchor. The Heidegger-mediation counterpressure was discharged at 2026-05-04 by direct comparison with Heidegger's BGE 56 reading (Vollendung-narrative subsumption) vs MP's reading (indirect ontology). The H&T 1947 ingest does not introduce a new MP-Nietzsche reading; SB 1942 contains no Nietzsche material; CPP contains no direct Nietzsche citation; DD 2024 and Morris 2024 do not engage Nietzsche. The supported claim's evidence chain is self-contained within the V&I working notes + Chouraqui 2014/2016 + Heidegger-side comparison.
ingested-corpus-four-element-gap 2026-04-27 (created); reaffirmed 2026-05-04 Anchor still holds The negative-evidence enumeration of 18 secondary-source attestation counts is a corpus-state claim; Tier 1 ingests of MP primary texts (SB 1942, CPP, H&T 1947) do not alter the secondary-source count. Morris 2024 and DD 2024 (both newly ingested secondary sources) would be additions to the table; verifying their attestation counts: Morris 2024 has 0 science secrète, 0 coherent deformation, ~3 chiasm cognates, 1 Stiftung-related (institution as eruption); DD 2024 has 0 science secrète, 0 coherent deformation, 0 chiasm-as-named, ~10 institution / Stiftung-related. Neither newly ingested secondary source occupies the four-element synthesis, so the supported claim's negative-evidence finding is reinforced rather than weakened. The corpus-table itself in claims.md could be refreshed at next lint to add Morris 2024 + DD 2024 rows.
malraux-schema-precedes-mp-coherent-deformation-philological-refinement 2026-04-28 (Malraux 1953 ingest) Anchor still holds Negative finding (zero hits for "coherent deformation" in Stuart Gilbert's English) is empirically secure. The French-source (Pléiade Voix du silence 1951 / Skira 1947–49 Psychologie de l'art) hard-absence is preserved; no new ingest discharges this. Newer ingests do not alter the philological observation.
sb-1942-kinetic-melody-origin 2026-05-05 (this run) Anchor still holds — fresh Promoted to supported this run; the SB source-page Key Passages section quotes raw 402–404 + raw 982–984 + raw 1144 + raw 1218–1222 + raw 1528 directly. Verified against raw/The Structure of Behavior (Merleau-Ponty Maurice).md at the relevant line numbers (raw 1144 = "kinetic melody" + "qualitatively modifies its beginning and the physiognomy of the whole" verified). No Rule 18 re-anchoring required because the supported promotion was made on the basis of the new ingest's anchoring.

Additional Rule 18 verifications performed this run beyond the supported-claim set:

  • SB Ch IV note 50 raw 2653 verification. The seventh-run report (line 71) recorded that the synthesis-agent verified this passage. Independent re-verification this run: grep -n "Formale\|original passivity\|secondary passivity\|natural body\|cultural body" against the raw file returns the verbatim footnote at raw 2653: "Nevertheless there would be a place for investigating more thoroughly the distinction of our 'natural body,' which is always already there, already constituted for consciousness, and our 'cultural body,' which is the sedimentation of its spontaneous acts. The problem is posed by Husserl when he distinguishes 'original passivity' and 'secondary passivity.' Cf. in particular 'Formale und transzendentale Logik,' in Jahrbuch für Philosophie und phänomenologische Forschung, X (1929), p. 287." The local context (Ch IV §Truth of Naturalism, the soul/body relativization passage at raw 1934 and the "El Greco case" passage at raw 1884–1888) confirms that the footnote is attached to a substantive doctrinal claim about embodied dialectics, not a passing reference. mp-1942-already-prefigures-late-sedimentation (live) anchor confirmed; reading still warrants the live status.

  • HT Ch. V "humanism of comprehension" cardinal quote verification. The seventh-run report (line 73) recorded verification. Independent re-check this run: grep -n humanism against raw/humanism-and-terror-an-essay-on-the-communist-problem-maurice-merleau-ponty.md returns at raw 1477 the verbatim passage: "Western humanism is a humanism of comprehension—a few mount guard around the treasure of Western culture; the rest are subservient. ... it has nothing in common with a humanism in extension, which acknowledges in every man a power more precious than his productive capacity..." The local context (Ch. V on Koestler's Yogi/Commissar binary; the structural alternative MP develops via the proletariat as third term) confirms the structural-pair coinage status. humanism-of-comprehension-vs-extension (live) anchor confirmed.

  • Morris 2024's BNF temps fondant note is not in raw/; this is a hard absence. The Morris source page acknowledges this explicitly (line 271: "Not in raw/; Morris is the wiki's first source for this archival reference."). The wild-being-extends-to-physics (live) and time-as-late-mp-privileged-ontological-clue (candidate) and quantum-systems-exhibit-merleau-pontian-wild-structure (candidate) all depend on Morris's reading of an archive Morris himself has not directly engaged. No Rule 18 verification possible without Morris-side archival access; the limit is durable and recorded in the seventh-run report.

Hard-absence catalog

Drawn from the seventh-run report Hard absences section + extraction-note references that imply absences:

Absence Gates / blocks
Saint Aubert 2006 Vers une ontologie indirecte (Vrin) Saint Aubert backlog Priority A pages (5); science-secrete-stiftung-chiasm (live → would-be supported); wild-being-extends-to-physics (corroboration / qualification by 2006 framework); time-as-late-mp-privileged-ontological-clue (candidate). Hardest-blocking single absence per synthetic-layer-2026-05-05.md line 256.
Beauvoir Le deuxième sexe (1949) mp-beauvoir-1949-convergence-on-gender (candidate); CPP ch. 7 §IX integration on [[gender-as-cultural-developmental]].
Berghofer-Wiltsche 2024 Phenomenology and QBism wild-structure Open Question on cross-source attestation; possible wild-being-extends-to-physics live → supported promotion.
Reynolds 2002 / 2004 parergon-cezanne-mp-outlines-structural-parallel (candidate, low) → live.
Saint Aubert 2013 Du corps au désir (= Être et chair I) desire / body / vrai dehors concept-page integration; cross-references to E&C II.
Andén 2019 (JBSP) named at AUDIT_PLAN Briefing line 82 as wiki-referenced-but-unverified author; gates spot-check.
De Warren 2018 (Brill chapter on Eye and Mind) named at Briefing line 82; gates spot-check.
Steinbock named at Briefing line 82; specific work not pinned down.
Morris's BNF temps fondant note (January 1959) The single archival anchor for wild-being-extends-to-physics (live), time-as-late-mp-privileged-ontological-clue (candidate). Not in raw/; Morris himself did not directly transcribe the note.
Baffier 2012 (Médium) DD 2024 source page lists this as not-on-the-wiki entity; the morphological attribution of Crooked Finger handprints is the empirical anchor for passence-as-mp-presence-of-absence (candidate) and the Crooked Finger paradigm case. Currently DD 2024 mediates the citation.
Heinbokel 2024 (From Johann to Maurice) In raw/ but not yet ingested (raw inventory item #24). Currently flagged as a false-friend caution on [[coherent-deformation]]. Not blocking any live claims; would discharge the false-friend Open Question if ingested.

Multi-source contextualizations

Per the audit brief, identify pages where Phase 8 synthesis depends on a single-source anchor that newer ingests have multi-source contextualized. Given the seventh-run pattern, candidates:

  • [[chiasm]] and Carbone 2004 / Carbone 2015 / Carbone 2019 stack. Carbone 2004 was ingested 2026-04-28; the chiasm page line 268 acknowledges the foundational a-philosophy anchor. The page already cites all three Carbone volumes. The seventh-run synthesis-layer report does NOT identify a new multi-source contextualization here.
  • [[wild-being]] triangulation: Knight 2024 (Schelling), Saint Aubert 2021 (épreuve mutuelle), Morris 2024 (physics). Three independent late-MP readings now triangulate wild-being, each developed in a separate secondary source. The wild-being page integrates all three under separate subsections. Lead may consider expanding the Synthetic Claims section to articulate a "tri-source convergence" candidate if an interpretive thesis is available; not yet visible from extraction notes.
  • [[institution]] triangulation: Beith 2018, Faul 2024, Inkpin 2026, Sorbonne CPP. Four independent secondary readings now anchor institution. The page is rich. The seventh-run cite-backs added 3 entries; the page is already at 2026-05-05 update.
  • [[melody]] HUB cluster: SB 1942 (now supported origin), Beith 2018, Decarie-Daigneault 2025, Carbone 2004. SB 1942 supported promotion this run shifts the genealogical anchor to 1942; the broader cluster (interanimality, motor-intentionality, institution, fundamental-thought-in-art, wild-structure / wild-being) inherits the shift. Lead's Step 8.5 Synthetic Claims expansion candidates after this shift are visible — the genealogical re-attribution is now consequential for these five wiki homes; the seventh-run line 191 already names them as cite-back deferred. No new claim is required; the existing supported claim's wiki homes list is the authorization.
  • [[bergson]] reading: DD 2024 + DD 2025 + Morris 2024. Three independent papers now articulate aspects of Bergson-MP-Deleuze convergence. The bergson-mp-deleuze-naissance-continue (live) claim Sources field was updated at the 2026-05-05 ingest. Morris 2024 adds Bergson's Matière et mémoire (1896) anticipation of wave-particle duality; the henri-bergson entity page does not yet record this reading per Morris source-page line 232 ("This bears on the henri-bergson entity page (which currently does not record this reading)"). High-yield Lead-applicable interpretive addition.

Verbatim block (items 1–10)

  1. Scope read: Phase 4 (major-volume integration triage on five Tier 1 ingests + Tier 2 light-touch) + Phase 5 (Rule 18 retrospective verifications + hard-absence catalog + multi-source contextualization scan).
  2. Files inspected: wiki/.audit/raw-inventory-2026-05-05.md; wiki/.audit/saint-aubert-backlog.md; wiki/.audit/synthetic-layer-2026-05-05.md; full source pages merleau-ponty-1942-structure-of-behavior, merleau-ponty-2010-child-psychology-pedagogy, morris-2024-wild-structure-melting-time, decarie-daigneault-2024-crooked-finger, merleau-ponty-1947-humanism-and-terror; concept pages wild-being, wild-structure, transtemporality, passence, double-sided-artifact, encounter-deleuze, melting-time, chiasm, indirect-ontology, historical-responsibility; entity page nikolai-bukharin; spot checks of passivity, sedimentation, stiftung, transitivism, syncretic-sociability, hyper-reflection, lebenswelt, ontological-difference, nonphilosophy, convergence-thesis-mp, lateral-universal; wiki/claims.md Summary table + supported-claim entries (6) + seventh-run additions; merleau-ponty-1955-adventures-of-the-dialectic structure-only.
  3. Raw sources inspected: raw/The Structure of Behavior (Merleau-Ponty Maurice).md (verified Ch IV note 50 raw 2653 — Husserl Formale und transzendentale Logik 1929 citation + natural-body / cultural-body / sedimentation framework attached to Ch IV §Truth of Naturalism); raw/humanism-and-terror-an-essay-on-the-communist-problem-maurice-merleau-ponty.md (verified raw 1477 — humanism of comprehension / humanism in extension structural-pair).
  4. Claims or pages affected: zero edits performed (report-only). 32 distinct triage findings catalogued: 8 mechanical Lead-applicable, 11 Phase 8 cite-back deferred (matching the seventh-run report's deferred queue + 2 SB-1942 supported framing updates beyond it), 8 next-ingest-cycle interpretive defers, 5 hard-absence-gated.
  5. Findings ranked: medium-high. The Phase 8 seventh run discharged 13 cite-backs (per line 181) of the ~25 that the synthetic layer's 19 register actions implicate. The remaining ~12 are concrete and trackable; none are blocked by hard absences. Three SB-1942-anchored cite-backs (passivity, sedimentation, stiftung) are the most consequential because the live claim mp-1942-already-prefigures-late-sedimentation ought to be visible on the three pages it names as wiki homes. The Saint Aubert 2026-04-25 backlog is intact at 5 Priority A + 10 Priority B pages — no progress in 10 days, principally gated by Saint Aubert 2006 hard absence.
  6. Evidence anchors per finding: Rule 18 verifications anchored at SB raw 2653 + HT raw 1477 (verbatim cross-checked against raw files); seventh-run cite-back queue at synthetic-layer-2026-05-05.md lines 165–198 (specifically lines 185–198 deferred); seventh-run lint-level findings at lines 242–247 (slug-mis-points and Meta drift); Saint Aubert backlog at saint-aubert-backlog.md Priority A (5) + Priority B (10); raw-inventory hard absences at raw-inventory-2026-05-05.md lines 80–90.
  7. Recommended action: Lead applies items 1–8 (8 mechanically clear cite-back / Sources / slug fixes); Agent E picks up items 9–19 (11 Phase 8 cite-back tasks for next run); items 20–27 deferred to next ingest cycle for interpretive work; items 28–32 recorded as durable hard-absence gates. No supported promotions implicated this audit; no live → supported pathway opens without Saint Aubert 2006 / Beauvoir / Berghofer-Wiltsche / Reynolds ingests.
  8. Cross-references: Agent B (silent-key + motif delta) — SB 1942 melody HUB origin shift validates Agent B's expected motif-delta finding; Agent C (citation integrity) — Rule 18 verifications confirm citation traceability for the 6 supported claims with no fabrication risk; Agent E (Phase 8) — 11 cite-back tasks queued for next-run discharge, with no halts at the supported gate (no new supported promotions implied by this audit).
  9. Confidence/status before → after: zero claim or page status changes from this audit (report-only). The supported-claim set (6) and the live-claim set (43) are stable as of the seventh-run end-state.
  10. Report-only: no wiki edits.