Weave Pass 3 — Row-32 counter-test re-scan: aletheia ↔ dehiscence (2026-06-02)

Type: structural-isomorphism re-scan (operational .audit/ artifact; not a wiki page). Trigger: next-actions.md row 32 — counter-test ingest gate for Bridge Card 1 (aletheia-dehiscence-cross-tradition-self-differentiation, signed off + applied 2026-05-17 as the first Latent-Adjacent precedent). Lawlor (2003) + Madison (1981) now ingested; row-32 done-when = "re-run structural-isomorphism-scanner on aletheia ↔ dehiscence." Scanner: structural-isomorphism-scanner subagent (Opus 4.8), read-only.

Verdict: LATENT-ADJACENT (sustained) — no upgrade, no retraction

The counter-test discharges the row-32 blocker with the verdict UNCHANGED. Decision branch: Latent-Adjacent → current state stands. The *has cross-tradition cousin* typed connections on aletheia + dehiscence are CONFIRMED (no upgrade to *structural-parallel*); no claims.md candidate authorized (v0d.9 bars candidate emission on Latent-Adjacent).

Triple-test (rejection / substitute / grounding)

  • (i) Rejection — ALIGNED. Both reject an externally-additive model and substitute internal constitution: Heidegger rejects concealment-as-shadow-added-to-light (Lethe als das Herz der A-letheia, GA 14 p. 88); MP rejects the second-leaf-added-to-the-first ("never been apart"). Lawlor corroborates the MP side (écart as negativity internal to being).
  • (ii) Substitute form — ALIGNED. Self-differentiation as positive structure: "Lichtung der sich verbergenden Anwesenheit" / visibility "splits itself into seer and seen." Axis-(ii)+ positive-form sharing (v0d.9 sharpened criterion), not merely a shared negative property.
  • (iii) Grounding — NOT ALIGNED (registrally divergent across the tradition boundary). Heidegger: destinal Seinsgeschichte / Es-Geben / Lichtung-as-unconcealment. MP: carnal flesh-as-element / intra-ontology / vertical Being. Madison makes the divergence explicit and self-conscious.

What the ingest changed

  • Madison 1981 = decisive, and it STRENGTHENS the divergence. Reads MP's late ontology as an intra-ontology and question-savoir expressly distinguished from Heideggerian Seinsfrage; routes MP through a Pyrrhonian counter-tradition contrasted with Heidegger; uses Lichtung only in the "natural light"/flesh register (VI 142/187; extraction lines 305, 357). The lone Heidegger–MP contact at the dehiscence locus — "a primordial articulation or dehiscence — an 'Auseinandersetzung' or polemos, as Heidegger would say" (extraction line 312 / Madison l. 1449) — is naming-level (imports the Introduction to Metaphysics strife-term into MP's flesh-apparatus), engine-terminus-contained, and survives the v0d.9 auto-identification clause.
  • Lawlor 2003 = orthogonal to the hinge. "dehiscence" does not appear; the MP↔Derrida (écart-as-différance) comparison runs through chiasm / écart / Stiftung, not dehiscence and not aletheia. aletheia appears once — Deleuze's third power of the question reveals "not aletheia but errancy" (DR 253/196; extraction line 851), i.e. positioned against the bridge. Lawlor supplies no dehiscence-as-différance bridge.

Five-condition Latent-Adjacent signature (v0d.9) — re-verified; all hold (more securely than pre-ingest)

(i)+(ii) align across the tradition boundary; (iii) diverges registrally — now positively evidenced by Madison; the divergence is cross-tradition; strict Iso would require ignoring it; auto-identification operates at the naming-level (Madison's "as Heidegger would say"), not apparatus-merge.

Pattern #11 (too-clean bridge) — passes by declining to upgrade

The one Iso-pointing datum (dehiscence-as-polemos) imports a terminus term, not the destinal engine; reading it as Iso-evidence would be the exact engine-terminus conflation Pattern #11 guards against. The conservative reading is correct.

Dastur leg

Downgraded from blocker → optional enrichment. Madison already supplies the axis-(iii) Lichtung-translatability test the Dastur (Lichtung / clairière) leg was queued to probe, and resolves it against Iso. Dastur could add philological texture but cannot flip Latent-Adjacent → Iso given the grounding divergence is now positively attested.

Applied writes (within the Open-Questions carve-out)

  • De-hedged the Latent-Adjacent caution on aletheia + dehiscence Open Questions to "counter-test discharged 2026-06-02, verdict held."
  • *has cross-tradition cousin* connections: unchanged. No claims.md candidate. No motif-weight change.
  • next-actions.md row 32 → done (verdict held); Dastur leg downgraded.

Load-bearing locators

  • Iso-pointing-but-contained: .extraction-madison-1981-phenomenology-merleau-ponty.md line 312 (Madison raw l. 1449) — polemos / Auseinandersetzung, naming-level.
  • Axis-(iii) divergence: Madison source page Core Arguments 5/6/7/9 + Key Findings; .extraction-madison lines 305, 357 (Lichtung = natural light / flesh).
  • Lawlor "no dehiscence-as-différance": .extraction-lawlor-2003-thinking-through-french-philosophy.md line 851 (Deleuze errancy contra aletheia, DR 253/196).