Silent-Key Scan — Phase 2 Report (post-2026-05-05 delta)
Date: 2026-05-07 Audit phase: Phase 2 (subsequent-run single-pass scan) Scope: 2 sources ingested after the 2026-05-05 silent-keys-delta scan filed: Saint Aubert 2006 Vers une ontologie indirecte and Mendoza-Canales (ed.) 2026 Institution-Ontology-Politics (Brill). Protocol: silent-keys-2026-04-25.md §1c (validated; no revision required). Per AUDIT_PLAN v1.5 R7, subsequent-run mode reverts to single-pass scan over new sources. Output policy: report only — no wiki page edits this run. Cross-reference candidates already absorbed by the 2026-05-07 motifs-delta sweep are flagged in the verdict tables.
Corpus-level summary table
| Source | PASS | NEAR-MISS | REJECTED | Highest-weight finding | Recommended action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
saintaubert-2006-vers-une-ontologie-indirecte |
2 | 1 | 0 | endurance (du chaos) (carnal-perceptual analogue of binocular vision; Ch IV §1) | Subsection on [[ineinander]] or new section on a future [[hyperdialectique]] upgrade |
mendoza-canales-2026-institution-ontology-politics |
3 | 1 | 1 | deposited / déposer (4-chapter convergence on institution's mechanism; no wiki home) | Subsection on [[institution]] or [[stiftung]] |
| TOTAL | 5 | 2 | 1 |
Cross-reference to Phase 3 motif report (motifs-delta 2026-05-07): SA-2006's promiscuité candidate was already absorbed into the HUB cluster Ineinander / overlapping / empiètement / enveloppement / promiscuité de l'Être / nesting / trundling during the 2026-05-07 motifs-delta sweep — recorded as NEAR-MISS here rather than PASS, since the corpus-level promotion has already happened. M-C 2026's revolution-as-Stiftung, constituting-vs-instituting, non-philosophie, direct-vs-indirect-ontology, and the SA-2006 Heidegger-as-silenced-interlocutor and soil/Boden updates are all motifs.md entries as of 2026-05-07; the silent-key scan does not double-promote.
Source 1 — saintaubert-2006-vers-une-ontologie-indirecte
Tracker (Recurring Motifs from extraction note): direct vs indirect ontology (HUB), empiétement / promiscuité (HUB), ruines de pensée / effondrement (STRUCTURAL), fait primitif (STRUCTURAL), Heidegger as silenced interlocutor (HUB), non-philosophie (HUB), Brunschvicg as proto-target (STRUCTURAL), Blondel's L'Être et les êtres (STRUCTURAL), Piaget's La représentation de l'espace chez l'enfant (STRUCTURAL), co-naissance / naissance continuée (HUB), deux positivismes du langage (STRUCTURAL), diplopie ontologique → bonne/mauvaise dialectique → hyperdialectique (STRUCTURAL), idolâtrie / idoles (THEME).
Primary concepts: ontologie indirecte, non-philosophie, fait primitif, diplopie ontologique, anthropologisme vs anthropologie, priorité ontologique du monde perçu, endurance du chaos, deux positivismes du langage, supralapsaire pensée, topologie de la chair, espace topologique, idolâtrie permanente, imminence de la vérité, être de la chair / chair de l'être, scénario heideggérien (attenuated).
The extraction note's Pass 3 Part C pre-identified three silent-key candidates: endurance (du chaos), militante (philosophie / ontologie), promiscuité. Validated below.
| # | Candidate | Attestations | In tracker? | In primary? | Verdict | Work-test |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | endurance (du chaos) | Ch IV §1 section title; sparse elsewhere | NO | YES (in primary as endurance du chaos) | PASS | Names the attitude required for late ontology — distinct from Heideggerian Gelassenheit, distinct from Ent-schlossenheit, distinct from any pre-dialectical solution (tabula rasa or restoration). Carnal-perceptual analogue of binocular vision: holding contradictory monocular vues together until binocular form emerges. Listing under primary concepts is a marker that ingest-time recognized the term's load-bearing role; the silent-key gate confirms that despite frequency-low textual presence, removing the term collapses MP's positive response to deux positivismes into mere refusal. |
| 2 | militante (philosophie / ontologie) | 3+ attestations: raw 1047 ("toute philosophie existante est militante"), raw 1287 (Introduction 1958 "ontologie militante"), raw 1678 (Être et Monde "ontologie militante") | NO | NO | PASS | Names MP's attitude required for indirect ontology — committed engagement with the empirical, the partial. Distinct from philosophie triomphante. Without it, indirect ontology reduces to negative-via-Heidegger; with it, indirection becomes positive-engagement. The 1947→1958→post-1958 attestation arc tracks the maturation of the term into MP's late lexicon. |
| 3 | promiscuité | 6-7 attestations: raw 1079 (Blondel-reading), raw 1620 ("promiscuité de l'Être" Piaget critique), raw 1670 (Conclusion §1) | YES (Ineinander HUB cluster, updated 2026-05-07) | NO | NEAR-MISS | Originally flagged at ingest as positionally load-bearing for the chair-and-being relation (the active-ignorance dimension that empiétement does not name). Since the 2026-05-07 motifs-delta sweep, promiscuité de l'Être has been folded into the Ineinander / overlapping / empiètement / enveloppement / promiscuité de l'Être / nesting / trundling HUB entry — corpus-level promotion already accomplished. The silent-key status is verified, then absorbed: not REJECTED-as-tracked at ingest time, but tracker-resolved by the same-day motifs work. No new action. |
Recommended action:
- endurance (du chaos): subsection on
[[ineinander]]or[[hyperdialectique]](existing or future). Could also anchor a short note on[[good-ambiguity]]since endurance names the affective-attitudinal correlate of the binocular form. Defer to Phase 8 Step 8.5 or future-audit concept-page upgrade — not a new-page candidate (single-volume primary attestation; corpus weight insufficient for HUB). - militante (philosophie / ontologie): subsection on
[[indirect-ontology]]under a future "What the Concept Does" or "Stakes" section, or typed-connection upgrade on[[hyperdialectique]]. Defer to Phase 8 Step 8.5. - promiscuité: no action — already in motifs.md HUB cluster.
Cross-reference to motifs delta: SA-2006's three pre-identified silent keys (endurance, militante, promiscuité) all sit inside MP's authorial vocabulary as transmitted by SA — SA does not coin them. The silent-key gate here is confirming SA's archival-philological reading rather than promoting SA-coinages.
Source 2 — mendoza-canales-2026-institution-ontology-politics
Tracker (Corpus-level Recurring Motifs from the 12-chapter extraction note): institution / Stiftung (HUB cross-chapter), revolution-as-Stiftung / mise-en-question (HUB), constituting vs instituting subject (HUB), trans-temporality / "the past that could have been otherwise" (STRUCTURAL — but flagged at silent-key tier by Larison), diacritical structure / écart (HUB), dialectic-without-synthesis (HUB), hyper-dialectique (HUB), flesh of history (HUB), barbarous principle / Earth (STRUCTURAL), Sinnesboden / soil-as-a-priori (STRUCTURAL), perceptual faith / belief / saturated attention (STRUCTURAL), proletariat as institution (STRUCTURAL), event vs institution (STRUCTURAL), Bloch / utopia / non-blueprint (THEME), imaginary as ratio essendi (STRUCTURAL).
Primary concepts: Stiftung-becoming (vs Stiftung-foundation), instituting subject, constituting subject (contrast term), revolution-as-mise-en-question, trans-temporality, hyper-dialectic, dialectic-without-synthesis, organismal institution, autopoietic-vs-institutional teleology, Sinnesboden / soil, membrure, diacritical conception, saturated attention, voir-selon / vivre-selon, dialectical imagination, vortex-tourbillon, imaginary texture of the real, proletariat-as-institution, anti-humanistic humanism, Aristotle-inversion (theory-praxis).
The extraction note's corpus-level Pass 3 Part C pre-identified eight silent-key candidates. Per protocol cap (3 per source), the three strongest cross-chapter candidates are validated below; the remaining five are tabled separately as below-cap notes.
| # | Candidate | Attestations | In tracker? | In primary? | Verdict | Work-test |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | deposited / "deposit a sense" / déposer | 4 chapters (León 3863; Caraus 285-286; Mendoza-Canales 1826; Pagan implicitly); MP source-text I&P 77 | NO (motifs.md absorbs sedimentation but not déposer explicitly) | NO | PASS | Names the precise mechanism by which institution is neither pure event nor pure residue — the verb-form that lets MP say events "deposit a sense in me, not just as something surviving or as a residue, but as the call to follow." 4-chapter cross-author convergence. Without it, institution collapses into either constitutive-act (subject pole) or sedimented-residue (object pole); the dynamic-call dimension drops out. |
| 2 | "the past that could have been otherwise" | 1 (Larison 4464); never named as a thesis in the volume itself | NO | NO (tabled in tracker as part of trans-temporality) | PASS | Modal hinge that converts Chauí's epistemological-political thesis (theory-points-to-the-possible) into an ontological one. Underwrites Larison's reading of trans-temporality as the condition of possibility for the theory-praxis inversion. Used once but does positional-pivotal work: removing it leaves Larison's thesis as merely epistemological-Marxist; with it, trans-temporality becomes ontological. The HUB-grade flag at extraction time is correct; not promoted to motifs because single-source for now, but flagged to track if a second source attests. |
| 3 | "haunts" / "obsessive presence" / "haunting" | Caraus 277, 293 (cross-references PhP proletariat as "obsessive presence" with I&P question that "haunts"); Dufourcq §§1-2 (Schwebung / phantom / hovering); Lanzirotti §4-§5 (flesh as "thickness") | NO | NO | PASS | Cross-chapter convergence on the modal-temporal register of how things persist in MP without being present. Caraus identifies the PhP↔I&P phrase-level convergence; Dufourcq cross-anchors via Schwebung; Lanzirotti's "thickness" overlaps. Removing the cluster leaves Caraus's "the proletariat persists in late MP" as biographical-rhetorical; with the cluster, persistence becomes a structural-ontological mode. Possible cross-source motif candidate (hauntology-in-MP) — flag for Phase 3 next-audit. |
| – | taken up / reprendre | León 3879, 3825; Mendoza-Canales (Stiftung-becoming); Pagan; Caraus | YES (reprise.md covers the reprise / Nachvollzug register; motifs.md HUB entry "reprise / taking-up-the-past" updated 2026-05-04) |
NO | NEAR-MISS | Tracker absorbs the simpler reprise register, but the operative role of reprendre as the differentiator between instituting and constituting (the instituted is that which can be taken up again) is not yet typed on [[reprise]] or [[institution]]. The silent-key role is structural; the motif-tracker entry is rhetorical. Recommend typed-connection upgrade on [[reprise]] referring to instituting-as-takable-up; defer to Phase 8 Step 8.5. |
| – | saturated attention | Chouraqui 4090, 4282 | YES (saturated-attention.md page exists since tenth-run, 2026-05-07) |
YES | REJECTED — page exists. Triage now anchors to existing [[saturated-attention]] page. |
Below-cap note (5 single-chapter or specialized candidates):
| # | Candidate | Source-internal location | Verdict | Recommended action |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4 | "appear too soon" / "lacked density" (temporal criterion) | Pagan §3 (raw 861, AdV 64) | NEAR-MISS (single-chapter) | Subsection on [[institution]] or [[stiftung]] as load-bearing temporal criterion for what counts as instituted; cross-check with 1953-55 sources. |
| 5 | "recentered" / "reabsorbed" (mechanism absorbing radical novelty) | Pagan §3 (raw 965, I&P 39-40) | NEAR-MISS (single-chapter) | Tension-flag on [[institution]] for the event-vs-institution problem in later MP. |
| 6 | "medial language" / "constellation" | Kaushik §1 (line 3130) | NEAR-MISS (single-chapter, methodological) | Cross-link to [[matrixed-ontology]] or future expression concept page. |
| 7 | "phenomenon-envelope" / macrophenomenon (Ruyer) | Halák §2-§4 (fn 38, fn 50) | NEAR-MISS (single-chapter, technical) | Subsection on [[organismal-institution]] or [[mechanism-vitalism]] (existing tenth-run stubs) — wholes-without-closure register. |
| 8 | "vortex that we are" (rather than "in which") / l'étoffe imaginaire du réel / "approximation" as method | Dufourcq §§1-2 (pp. 192-202) | NEAR-MISS (single-chapter cluster) | Anchor on [[vortex-tourbillon]] and [[imaginary-mp]] (existing tenth-run stubs); l'étoffe imaginaire du réel particularly compresses Dufourcq's whole thesis. |
The chapter-level silent keys (Pagan: "appear too soon", "on the basis of"; Fava: Sinnesboden, Spielraum, Urhistorie; Mendoza-Canales: "adventure", "materialist ontology", "momentum"; Halák: "phenomenon-envelope", "empathy" / coexister avec, "matter refers to the future"; Lanzirotti: "diacritical conception", "intermediate"/"vehicle"; Chouraqui: "saturated attention", "crystallization", "clean-hands problem as bivalence problem"; Popa: "substruction", "kinship", "autopoise"; Kaushik: "medial language" / "constellation", "figurative", "true illusion"; Dufourcq: vortex/étoffe/approximation; León: coexister, reprendre, fond; Larison: "the past that could have been otherwise", "each epoch anticipates and is late for itself", "more than the subject and less than the object"; Caraus: "deposited", "haunts", "temptation") are individually well-documented in the extraction note's per-chapter Part C sections. The corpus-level winnowing above privileges cross-chapter convergence over chapter-internal load-bearing.
Recommended action (M-C 2026 Tier 1 PASS candidates):
- deposited / déposer: subsection on
[[institution]]or[[stiftung]]— the precise verb-form names institution's mechanism; existing pages do not type it. Defer to Phase 8 Step 8.5 next pass (institution.md is already heavily worked from the ninth/tenth runs; one more upgrade fits). - the past that could have been otherwise: anchor on
[[time-mp]](if exists; check) or on thetime-as-late-mp-privileged-ontological-clueclaim entry's evidence section. Flag formp-painter-as-primary-witness-for-indirect-ontologycross-reference if relevant. Defer to Phase 8 Step 8.5. - haunts / obsessive presence / haunting: cross-source motif candidate — flag for next motifs-delta sweep when a second-author cross-attestation lands (Saint Aubert 2021 Ineinander / cristallisation may already provide the second anchor; check at next audit).
Cross-reference to motifs delta (2026-05-07): all five "below-cap" candidates have specific concept-page or stub-page anchors that already exist (institution, stiftung, organismal-institution, mechanism-vitalism, vortex-tourbillon, imaginary-mp, matrixed-ontology, saturated-attention). The motifs-delta sweep promoted revolution-as-another-Stiftung and constituting-vs-instituting-subject to corpus-HUB tier; the silent-key candidates above are positional-load-bearing terms that would feed those motif entries' "Operative anchors" field if expanded.
Cross-reference summary table (silent-key → motifs.md / wiki page)
| Silent key | Source | Existing motif/page anchor (2026-05-07) | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| endurance (du chaos) | SA-2006 | none — would seed [[ineinander]] or [[hyperdialectique]] subsection |
New PASS, defer |
| militante (philosophie / ontologie) | SA-2006 | none — would seed [[indirect-ontology]] Stakes or [[hyperdialectique]] typed connection |
New PASS, defer |
| promiscuité | SA-2006 | motifs.md HUB Ineinander / ... / promiscuité de l'Être / nesting / trundling (UPDATED 2026-05-07) |
NEAR-MISS, absorbed |
| deposited / déposer | M-C 2026 | none — would seed [[institution]] or [[stiftung]] mechanism subsection |
New PASS, defer |
| the past that could have been otherwise | M-C 2026 | none — single-chapter; flag for second-source confirmation | New PASS, defer |
| haunts / obsessive presence | M-C 2026 | none — possible cross-source motif (hauntology-in-MP) | New PASS, motif candidate |
| taken up / reprendre | M-C 2026 | motifs.md HUB reprise / taking-up-the-past / projet de l'avenir / Nachvollzug |
NEAR-MISS, typed-connection upgrade |
| saturated attention | M-C 2026 | [[saturated-attention]] page exists |
REJECTED, anchored |
Self-check
- Each source has 0–3 PASS candidates with verdicts and evidence anchors. ✓
- Each candidate verdict tested against current motifs.md (post-2026-05-07 motifs-delta state). ✓
- Cross-reference to motif-delta included for all silent keys whose corpus weight has shifted. ✓
- Single-pass scan (no validation/blind-pilot structure, per AUDIT_PLAN R7 subsequent-run mode). ✓
- Report-only output; no wiki page edits this run. ✓
- Below-cap candidates documented as NEAR-MISS without occupying PASS slots. ✓
1. Scope read
2. Files inspected (full paths)
3. Raw sources inspected: minimal (extraction-note-mediated reads only; raw-source verification deferred to next audit's Phase 6 if any sample touches these sources)
4. Claims or pages affected (citation only)
5. Findings ranked: blocker / high / medium / low
6. Evidence anchors per finding (extraction-note line numbers)
7. Recommended action
8. Cross-references to other phases' work expected
9. Confidence/status before → after for each affected motif/concept
10. Do not edit unless explicitly assigned — report only.
1. Scope read
2 Tier 1 extraction notes (post-2026-05-05); current motifs.md; baseline silent-keys-delta-2026-05-05.md.
2. Files inspected (full paths)
/Users/jeffreyvd/Documents/wikiwip/wiki/.audit/silent-keys-delta-2026-05-05.md/Users/jeffreyvd/Documents/wikiwip/wiki/.audit/silent-keys-2026-04-25.md/Users/jeffreyvd/Documents/wikiwip/wiki/motifs.md/Users/jeffreyvd/Documents/wikiwip/wiki/sources/.extraction-saintaubert-2006-vers-une-ontologie-indirecte.md/Users/jeffreyvd/Documents/wikiwip/wiki/sources/.extraction-mendoza-canales-2026-institution-ontology-politics.md- Concept-page existence spot-checks:
wiki/concepts/{nonphilosophy,anthropologisme,fait-primitif,empietement,saturated-attention,institution,stiftung,reprise,vortex-tourbillon,imaginary-mp,organismal-institution,mechanism-vitalism,matrixed-ontology,ineinander,hyperdialectique,indirect-ontology,recognition-and-institution,interdependence-claim,true-humanism,politics-mp,voir-selon-vivre-selon}.md
3. Raw sources inspected: minimal (extraction-note-mediated reads only)
4. Claims or pages affected (citation only — no edits this run)
- Concept pages with recommended subsections (deferred):
[[ineinander]],[[hyperdialectique]],[[indirect-ontology]],[[institution]],[[stiftung]],[[reprise]],[[time-mp]](existing? check),[[good-ambiguity]],[[organismal-institution]],[[mechanism-vitalism]],[[vortex-tourbillon]],[[imaginary-mp]],[[matrixed-ontology]],[[saturated-attention]]. - Possible cross-source motif candidate: haunts / obsessive presence / haunting (hauntology-in-MP) — for next motifs-delta sweep.
- No new concept page creations recommended this run; the SA-2006 + M-C 2026 silent-key residue feeds existing pages or recently-created stubs.
5. Findings ranked: blocker / high / medium / low
- Blocker: 0.
- High: 0 — both SA-2006 silent keys (endurance, militante) and the two non-tracker M-C 2026 silent keys (deposited, the past that could have been otherwise) are positional-load-bearing within their sources but are anchorable on existing or already-created concept pages; no high-priority new pages are required.
- Medium: 5 — endurance, militante, deposited, the past that could have been otherwise, haunts/obsessive presence — all defer to Phase 8 Step 8.5 next pass for subsection or typed-connection upgrades. haunts additionally surfaces as cross-source motif candidate.
- Low: 2 — promiscuité (NEAR-MISS, already absorbed by 2026-05-07 motifs-delta); taken up / reprendre (NEAR-MISS, typed-connection upgrade on
[[reprise]]).
6. Evidence anchors per finding (extraction-note line numbers)
Documented inline per candidate above; line numbers refer to the extraction notes, not raw sources.
7. Recommended action
Per source above. The non-deferrable item is the haunts / obsessive presence cross-source motif flag — when the next ingest produces a second non-M-C-2026 anchor, promote to motifs.md as new BRIDGE or STRUCTURAL motif (hauntology-in-MP / phantom register).
8. Cross-references to other phases' work expected
- Phase 3 (motifs-delta next sweep): haunts / obsessive presence candidacy; second-source confirmation pending.
- Phase 8 (next run, Step 8.5): subsection or typed-connection upgrades on
[[ineinander]],[[hyperdialectique]],[[indirect-ontology]],[[institution]],[[stiftung]],[[reprise]]for the five PASS / NEAR-MISS candidates above. - Phase 7 confidence addendum: no confidence shifts triggered by this scan.
9. Confidence/status before → after for each affected motif/concept
- endurance (du chaos): not-on-wiki → silent-key candidate, queue for Step 8.5 subsection.
- militante (philosophie / ontologie): not-on-wiki → silent-key candidate, queue for Step 8.5 typed-connection.
- promiscuité: not-yet-on-motifs.md → in motifs.md HUB cluster
Ineinander / ... / promiscuité de l'Être(already absorbed via 2026-05-07 motifs-delta). - deposited / déposer: not-on-wiki → silent-key candidate, queue for Step 8.5 subsection on
[[institution]]or[[stiftung]]. - the past that could have been otherwise: not-on-wiki → silent-key candidate, queue for Step 8.5 subsection on time-mp / institution-stiftung.
- haunts / obsessive presence: not-on-wiki → silent-key candidate + cross-source motif flag (await second non-M-C-2026 anchor).
- taken up / reprendre: motifs.md HUB unchanged → silent-key NEAR-MISS, queue for typed-connection upgrade on
[[reprise]]. - saturated attention: page exists → REJECTED-as-anchored.