2026-06-07
Citation Integrity Spot-Check — Sample Selection (2026-06-07 comprehensive audit, Phase 6)
Status: SAMPLE SELECTED — READ-ONLY. No verification performed yet. Verification is the next step.
Method: 20 citations selected, weighted by fabrication risk per AUDIT_PLAN Phase 6. Bias toward specific journal/volume/page references to works not in raw/ (highest fabrication risk). in-raw? = whether the cited work is present in raw/ (verifiable against original) vs. absent (verifiable only against the citing source's own footnotes/biblio, if that source is in raw). Risk: H/M/L.
Bucket allocation: 12 HEAVY (4 newest sources + derived concept pages) · 4 audit-produced/claim-home pages · 3 older pre-traceability MP concept pages · 1 Faul-pattern probe.
Newest-source raw presence (all 4 present): husserl-1954-crisis → Crisis (Carr) ✓ · bergson-1907-creative-evolution → Creative Evolution (Landes) ✓ · klossowski-1969-nietzsche-vicious-circle → Nietzsche and the Vicious Circle (Smith) ✓ · chouraqui-2025-europe-crisis-of-play → Europe as the Crisis of Play ✓.
Sample (1–20)
| # | Citing page | Citation (as written) | Claimed location | in-raw? | Risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | husserl-1954-crisis |
"It is through the garb of ideas that we take for true being what is actually a method." | §9.h (no inline Carr pagination; § locator only) | Y | M |
| 2 | mathematization-of-nature |
Carr's note that §9 has an "affinity with Koyré's Études galiléennes" | Open Questions; attrib. to Carr's Introduction | N (Koyré not in raw; Carr intro in raw) | H |
| 3 | paradox-of-human-subjectivity |
"It was wrong, methodically, to jump immediately into transcendental intersubjectivity and to leap over the primal 'I,' the ego of my epochē…" | §54 (§54b) | Y | M |
| 4 | bergson-1907-creative-evolution |
"the refutation of monism and of pantheism in general" — Bergson to Tonquédec, 1912 | Key Passages; Tonquédec correspondence (Landes reception dossier) | Y (dossier in raw) | M |
| 5 | elan-vital |
Deleuze: "the élan vital is duration that differentiates itself" | Positions; "Deleuze (1960)" / 1960 Saint-Cloud lectures (in Landes dossier) | Y (dossier in raw) | M |
| 6 | cinematographic-mechanism |
Le Dantec "notes he had independently used 'the cinematographic mechanism of thought' years earlier (in Le conflit)" | Positions; "Le Dantec (1907)" + EC 305 anchor | N (Le conflit not in raw; Le Dantec 1907 reply in dossier) | M |
| 7 | klossowski-1969-nietzsche-vicious-circle |
Foucault called it "the greatest book of philosophy I have read, with Nietzsche himself" | Summary ¶ + Connections; attrib. to Foucault (no location) | N (external attribution; not in chapter body) | H |
| 8 | vicious-circle-selective-doctrine |
"The Master and the slave are states which, respectively, are the result of a test." | Ch. 6 | Y | L |
| 9 | chouraqui-2025-europe-crisis-of-play |
William Pietz, "The Problem of the Fetish I" (Res 6, 1985) & "IIIa" (Res 16, 1988, p.109) | Sources / internal citation | N (Pietz not in raw; chapter in raw) | H |
| 10 | chouraqui-2025-europe-crisis-of-play |
Frank Chouraqui, "The Cognitivist Thesis of Nihilism" (Tijdschrift voor Filosofie 84:1, 2022) | Sources / Concepts Referenced ("cited, not in raw") | N (not in raw; chapter in raw) | H |
| 11 | play-element |
Huizinga, "You can deny seriousness but not play" (HL 3); civilization-division passage (HL 111) | quoted p.72 & p.74; Homo Ludens (Angelico 2016) pp. 3, 111, 207–10 | N (Huizinga not in raw; chapter in raw) | H |
| 12 | europe-as-crisis-of-play |
Angela Merkel, "wir schaffen das" (31 Aug 2015) — "a precise and sharp appeal to matching care with action" | p.66, endnote 3 (EN/DE) | N (speech not in raw; chapter+endnote in raw) | M |
| 13 | stiftung |
Carbone: Stiftung / "Indestructible Past" note read as "an institution, a system of equivalences" | Sources; Carbone 2004 — VI 238/184, VI 296/243, VI 298/244 | Y (Carbone 2004 in raw) | M |
| 14 | eternal-recurrence |
"Löwith (1935, Nietzsche's Philosophy of the Eternal Return of the Same)" reads ER as cosmological thesis in crisis | Positions | N (Löwith not in raw) | H |
| 15 | science-secrete |
"Every science secretes an ontology" | Signs p. 99 | Y (Signs in raw) | M |
| 16 | two-historicities |
MP "borrows 'advent' from Ricoeur" | Signs, p. 68, footnote 26 | Y (Signs in raw; Ricoeur orig. not in raw) | M |
| 17 | chiasm |
"It is a reversibility always imminent and never realized in fact… the coincidence eclipses at the moment of realization"; "zero of pressure between two solids" | V&I Ch 4, pp. 147–148 | Y (V&I in raw) | L |
| 18 | ecart |
Carbone's adjudication formula, Chiasmi International 4 [2002]: 57 (cited by Morin p. 192) | Positions; via Morin 2022 p. 192 | N (Chiasmi Intl not in raw; Morin 2022 in raw) | H |
| 19 | reversibility |
"two aspects of the reversibility which is the ultimate truth" | V&I Ch 4, p. 155 (closing line); cf. OE p. 65 / VI4 p. 204 | Y (V&I in raw) | M |
| 20 | Faul-pattern probe | Fabricated pattern: title "Painter's Courage" / "JBSP 55:2" attrib. to Faul / "JBSP 2024" | whole-wiki grep (body pages) | — | (probe) |
Faul-Pattern Probe Result (item 20)
VERDICT: fabricated pattern ABSENT from all wiki body pages. Real paper PRESENT, in raw, and correctly cited. CLEAN.
- Fabricated title "Painter's Courage": ZERO occurrences in any source/concept/entity/question body page. The string appears in the wiki only in governance/provenance/log files documenting the incident itself:
wiki/log.md(781, 795 — prior 2026-04-25 audit's clean-check record + Rule 16 motivation),wiki/claims.md(651 — Counterpressure block preserving the incident for traceability),wiki/schema-changelog.md(491 — Rule 16 provenance). All expected, none a live citation. Outsidewiki/:CLAUDE.md,AUDIT_PLAN.md,.claude/agents/*,.claude/skills/audit/SKILL.md— all incident-documentation, not citations. - "JBSP 55" / "JBSP … 2024" attributed to Faul: the only Faul + JBSP 55:2 + 2024 combination in the corpus is the real paper (see below). No fabricated variant.
- Real paper IS cited and IS in raw: "Ontologically Interactive Painting: On Susan Rothenberg's Three Heads," Caleb Faul, Journal of the British Society for Phenomenology 55:2, 184–197 (2024) — present at
raw/Faul_2024_Ontologically_Interactive_Painting.md. Cited acrosswiki/sources/faul-2024-ontologically-interactive-painting.md,wiki/entities/caleb-faul.md,wiki/entities/susan-rothenberg.md,wiki/concepts/interactive-ontology.md,wiki/concepts/institution.md,wiki/concepts/two-historicities.md,wiki/concepts/pregnancy-pragnanz.md, andwiki/index.md. - Note: the fabricated citation reused the real paper's journal/volume/year (JBSP 55:2, 2024) but swapped the title ("The Painter's Courage" ← fabricated; "Ontologically Interactive Painting" ← real). Verifiers checking other vague journal-vol-year references (esp. items 2, 7, 9, 10, 11, 14, 18 — works not in raw) should watch for the same title-swap-on-real-shell pattern.
Notes for the verifying pass
- Highest-priority (H, work not in raw, specific journal/vol/page or named-work-and-year): #2 (Koyré), #7 (Foucault attribution), #9 (Pietz Res 6/16), #10 (Chouraqui Tijdschrift 84:1), #11 (Huizinga HL 3/111/207–10), #14 (Löwith 1935), #18 (Chiasmi International 4 [2002]:57). For #9–#12 the citing chapter is in raw, so verify the wiki citation against the chapter's own footnotes/bibliography even though the cited work is absent.
- Primary-text § / page locators with no inline pagination in the OCR source (Husserl): #1, #3 — verify the § attribution against the Carr text in raw; pagination cannot be cross-checked (source carries no inline Carr pages).
- Reception-dossier citations (Bergson Landes edition): #4, #5 — these (Tonquédec, Deleuze 1960) are bound into the raw edition's appended dossier; verify against that dossier, not against standalone Deleuze/Tonquédec volumes.