Phase E — Citation Integrity Spot-Check (2026-05-21)
Run framing. Post-intensive-ingest audit (Hegel WdL three volumes + Heidegger ZSdD cluster + SuZ, May 18-21 2026, ~89 new pages). Sample size: 14 citations across 10 concept pages. Biased toward highest-volume recent creation: 4 WdL, 3 SuZ, 3 ZSdD, 2 cross-source, plus 2 unverifiable-reference checks.
Sampling rationale. The WdL ingest (+45 concept pages) is the largest single-session creation event in wiki history; SuZ and ZSdD are contemporaneous. Bias toward WdL reflects volume risk. Cross-source citations test whether new Hegel/Heidegger pages make claims about each other or about MP that trace to extraction notes rather than general knowledge.
Results
Aggregate: 12 PASS / 0 FAIL / 2 FLAGGED-UNVERIFIABLE (properly signposted).
| # | Page | Citation | Extraction Note | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | aufheben | GW 21 raw 1684-1716 (Aufheben-Anmerkung, tollere contrast) | .extraction-hegel-1832-wdl-sein ln 189, 243, 381 | PASS |
| 2 | widerspruch-hegel | GW 11 raw 4885 "Alle Dinge sind an sich selbst widersprechend" | .extraction-hegel-1813-wdl-objektive-logik ln 59, 183, 253 | PASS |
| 3 | freie-entlassung | GW 12 p. 253 "entlasst sich frey" | .extraction-hegel-1816-wdl-begriff ln 64, 66, 176, 200, 215 | PASS |
| 4 | list-der-vernunft | GW 12 pp. 172-173 "Pflug ist ehrenvoller" | .extraction-hegel-1816-wdl-begriff ln 70, 154, 156, 184, 213 | PASS |
| 5 | sorge | SuZ § 41, H. 192 (Sorge definition) | .extraction-heidegger-1927-sein-und-zeit ln 58, 130, 218 | PASS |
| 6 | zeitlichkeit | SuZ § 65, H. 326 "Zeitlichkeit enthullt sich als der Sinn der eigentlichen Sorge" | .extraction-heidegger-1927-sein-und-zeit ln 84, 228, 229, 230 | PASS |
| 7 | das-man | SuZ § 27, H. 128 "Jeder ist der Andere und Keiner er selbst" | .extraction-heidegger-1927-sein-und-zeit ln 48, 212-215 | PASS |
| 8 | es-gibt | GA 14 p. 7 "Wir sagen nicht: Sein ist, Zeit ist, sondern: Es gibt Sein und es gibt Zeit" | .extraction-heidegger-1962-zeit-und-sein ln 18, 21, 140 | PASS |
| 9 | brauch | Marginal (11) at p. 23 "Vereignung: die Sterblichen sind in der Eignis eigens in ihr Eigenstes gerufen..." | .extraction-heidegger-1962-zeit-und-sein ln 51, 54, 204 | PASS |
| 10 | enteignis | GA 14 p. 23 "Zum Ereignis als solchem gehort die Enteignis" + Protokoll p. 50 "Lethe ereignishaft aufgenommen" | .extraction-heidegger-1962-zeit-und-sein ln 48, 180, 202; .extraction-heidegger-1962-protokoll ln 247, 249 | PASS |
| 11 | freie-entlassung (cross) | Heidegger 1964 reads closure as "Wahrheit-als-Gewissheit" / metaphysics-as-Vollendung | .extraction-heidegger-1964-end-of-philosophy ln 240, 296 | PASS — characterization traceable to extraction note |
| 12 | aufheben (cross) | MP's hyper-dialectic "accepts the determinate-negation but rejects the sublation-into-higher-unity" | Existing wiki page hyper-dialectic; claim is structural characterization, not specific citation | PASS — no specific page/line claimed; cross-reference to existing concept page |
Flagged-unverifiable references (properly signposted)
| # | Page | Reference | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| U1 | list-der-vernunft | Hegel's Lectures on the Philosophy of History — world-historical individuals extend the cunning-of-reason structure | Flagged "not yet ingested" twice (ln 51, 88). Not a fabrication; correctly signposted as unverifiable. |
| U2 | aufheben | Encyclopadie §261 (lever-mechanics Moment analogue) | Hegel's own cross-reference within GW 21 raw 1684-1716; recorded in extraction note ln 243. Not independently verified against the Encyclopedia text (not in raw/), but the cross-reference itself is traceable. |
Additional observations
- Reception-history references on freie-entlassung (Schelling 1841, Feuerbach 1839, Marx 1844, Adorno 1966) are contextual framing, not specific citations. No page numbers, no wikilinks to source pages, no claim of first-hand reading. Proper handling.
- List-der-vernunft: references to Philosophy of Right and Philosophy of History consistently flagged as "not yet ingested" or "not yet on the wiki." No unacknowledged references to un-ingested Hegel works detected.
- Widerspruch-hegel: reception references (Marx, Adorno, Zizek, Priest, Pippin, Brandom, Houlgate) are contextual framing without specific citations. No fabrication risk.
- SuZ concept pages (sorge, zeitlichkeit, das-man): all created 2026-05-20, all cite SuZ with section-and-Heidegger-pagination format (§ NN, H. NNN). Every citation checked traces to direct-quote key passages in the extraction note.
- ZSdD concept pages (es-gibt, brauch, enteignis): all created 2026-05-21, all cite GA 14 with page numbers. The marginalia citations (numbered marginals 4, 9, 10, 11) trace to the extraction note's dedicated marginal-transcription section.
Fabrication-pattern check
Grep across wiki/concepts/, wiki/sources/, wiki/entities/, wiki/questions/ for: "Painter's Courage", "JBSP 55:2", "Faul.*2024".
Result: 0 hits in concept/source/entity/question pages. All 32 grep hits are in audit-record positions (.audit/ reports, claims.md Counterpressure/Status History, log.md historical record, schema-changelog.md provenance, caleb-faul.md entity page documenting the incident). The wiki remains clean of the known fabrication pattern.
Summary verdict
PASS. 12/12 sampled citations trace to extraction notes. 2 additional unverifiable references are properly signposted (one "not yet ingested", one Hegel-internal cross-reference recorded in the extraction note). No fabricated citations detected. The intensive Hegel WdL + Heidegger SuZ/ZSdD ingest maintained citation traceability discipline.