2026-06-02
Citation-Anchor Audit — CR-033 (2026-06-02)
Type: read-only citation-anchor verification (citation-verifier subagent, Opus). Operational .audit/ artifact.
Scope: the 5 supported-eligible live claims named in CR-033 (next-actions.md), checked before any supported-promotion review.
Headline: 24 evidence bullets — 13 PASS / 11 UNCERTAIN / 0 FAIL. No fabrication-class problems — every cited work has both a source page and a raw/ file; this is locator-precision, not the Faul (General Rule 16) pattern.
Worklist — anchors needing backfill before supported-promotion review (ranked by how fabrication-adjacent each reads under a hostile audit)
| # | Claim | Bullet | Defect | Backfill |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | time-as-late-mp-privileged-ontological-clue |
B1 (Morris) | Wrong locator — cited "Pass 2a item 33"; item 33 is the Smolin model, the time-clue statement is item 4. | FIXED 2026-06-02 → "item 4 (+ items 24, 25)". |
| 2 | time-as-late-mp-privileged-ontological-clue |
B2 (IP 36/7) | Locator-scheme mismatch — page "36/7" vs the extraction tag [4](3). |
Reconcile page-ref ↔ extraction tag (raw IP check). |
| 3 | time-as-late-mp-privileged-ontological-clue |
B3 (V&I particle physics) | Page-pairs 33–34/16–17, 235–236/185–186 not individually traced (only the working-note line is anchored). |
Verify each pair vs raw V&I working notes. |
| 4 | two-registers-of-vi |
B2 (V&I page list) | Aggregate, not per-page — only VI 215/220 are quote-anchored (membrure); the rest are Lanzirotti's seed aggregate. | Per-page register audit (the "systematic philological audit" the claim's own gate names). |
| 5 | dyadic-encounter-presupposes-institution |
B3 (PoW "lived solipsism") | Missing locator + mis-attribution — the phrase traces to PhP 373, not PoW. | Add PhP 373 (and/or PoW 139/141); Rule-18 targeted PoW check. |
| 6 | perceptual-faith-1946-1947-published-prefiguration |
B3 (S&NS "Man, the Hero" p. 217) | Page given but quote not traced in the extraction note (only pp. 95, 209 surfaced). | Confirm the p. 217 quote vs S&NS source page / raw. |
| 7 | revolution-and-reduction-as-structural-homology |
B2 (PhP preface) | No precise locator ("PhP preface" only). | Add the PhP preface page number. |
Not needing backfill: the four "not in raw/" Rule-16 framings (BNF note; Pagan's Duarte Penayo citation) are schema-compliant; the seven cross-corroboration bullets pointing at other [[claims#…]] entries are cross-refs, not passage anchors.
Status
- Item #1 fixed 2026-06-02 (this session:
time-as-late-mp-privileged-ontological-clueEvidence B1 + Status-History line +Updated:bump). - Items #2–7 need raw / extraction-note checks — tracked in
next-actions.md(CR-033 row). - No supported-promotion may proceed on these 5 claims until the named bullets carry locators. (The durable supported-promotion HALT applies regardless.)